Goodfella's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Grove

Review of Goodfella's Pizzeria, Grove, Oklahoma

Goodfella's Pizzeria, located at 8 W 3rd St, Grove, OK 74344, is a gem of a spot for anyone craving authentic Italian food. The pizza here is nothing short of delicious, with a flaky, perfectly crispy crust that rivals high-end pizzerias. The standout "Gangster Pizza" and "The Boss" come loaded with generous toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and fresh veggies, delivering bold flavors in every bite. Customers consistently praise the quality, with one reviewer calling it "the best pizza I’ve had in the last 25 years".

The drink selection is impressively large, offering everything from classic sodas like Barq's to cold beers, catering to a wide range of tastes. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, the variety ensures there's something for everyone.

What truly sets Goodfella's apart is the unbelievably friendly staff. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warm, welcoming service that makes you feel right at home. The atmosphere is cozy and family-friendly, with a clean dining area and ample parking, perfect for a relaxed meal. One customer noted, "Friendly staff, fast service, and delicious pizza! Just what we wanted".

As someone trying Italian food, I can confidently say, "I'm trying Italian food, and Goodfella's Pizzeria is a wonderful place!" This family-owned spot delivers exceptional pizza, a great drink selection, and a staff that goes above and beyond, making it a...

We travel for work constantly. During our travels, we like to try something local to the towns we are in for the week. We passed Goodfella's Pizzeria and knew we wanted to give it a try!! I placed my order for delivery and got it within 45 minutes. Small Pepperoni and small cheesy breadsticks. It got to our hotel and when I opened the box, I immediately knew this was going to be great food! The pepperoni were curled at the tops with the perfect amount of greasy goodness...sort of like a perfectly budding flower in the beginning of the spring!! I took a bite and OMG!! I am amazed. I read all the reviews and thought that this can't be one of the best pizza I have ever eaten if most people say "best pizza in Grove." Let me tell you...we live in OKC and travel the entire state and occasionally some different states. I have had OKC's best New York style pizza, all the local chains and also hit and miss places between. THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST PIZZAS I HAVE EVER EATEN!! Makes me look forward to returning in a year to have this pizza again!! May even be what we have for dinner tonight since this was lunch!!...

Even though I've been satisfied with the pizza from this location. I must leave a one star review for the 2 separate staff members, who became very defensive when I mentioned the online pricing. There is a difference in price, the website is clearly branded for the location in Grove. I do not expect the Internet to be perfect or even true for that matter. But, this has clearly been an issue which led to more of major frustration, an insulting response from the employees. As if I was an idiot for not knowing, and politely asking was beneath there ability too be service professionals. BUYER BEWARE someone on the Internet has lowered the menu items prices online to despite Goodfellas in Grove. HAHAHAHAHAHA

It's not about the cost difference, more importantly the snide response from the clearly unmotivated...