Schmidty's Old Mill Pub — Restaurant in Hamilton Township

Bartenders are awesome! There is Open-Mic Night every Tuesday evening; a small stage is set up inside. They also have a pool table, an electronic dart board, im pretty sure they have a cork board for darts but you'll have to bring your own darts. There is a covered deck outside for smokers and/or warm weather. There's an AMI Jukebox operable from your phone or it accepts cash, just purchase credits and play your favorite music. There is also an ATM but it works when it wants too. Prices of drinks are fair, food is great, also has a decent menu selection! The crowd varies each night. It could be a crowd in their 20's or a crowd in their 50's +. Sometimes there is mix of both younger and older people. It just depends on what is going on. For the most part its an interesting and good time when hanging out here. I recommend trying this place out if you haven't already. It's kind of small, but they have tables and then the bar seating. As well as additional seating outside. Parking lot is decent sized. I've seen it packed and I've seen it slow. It...

My first visit to Schmity's Old Mill Pub in Sciota, PA, was an absolute delight! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by Shelby, a veteran staff member who made me feel instantly welcome. It's clear she takes pride in making newcomers feel at home.

The atmosphere at Schmity's is fantastic – a fun, rustic vibe that's incredibly inviting. The pub is always thoughtfully decorated for each holiday, adding to the charm. The rest of the staff were equally friendly and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

The food was outstanding! I ordered the Pot Roast Kelly waffle fries, which were incredibly delicious and satisfying. The flavors were rich and comforting, and the portion size was perfect. I also shared an order of the parmesan garlic wings, and they were simply amazing! Perfectly cooked and seasoned, they were a definite highlight.

I highly recommend Schmity's Old Mill Pub to anyone looking for great food, a warm atmosphere, and friendly service. I'll definitely be back to explore more...

Gave a one star due to no other choices.Three ppl orders = chicken wings & mozzarella sticks, panini w/ roasted reds and potabella muchrooms ,onion rings, 2 slider burgers. Panini was served first with overdone onion rings, 5 minutes later wings arrived, 3 minutes later slider burgers. We began to eat and finally mozzarella sticks arrived. Apon tasting my first bite of panini there was this taste, only to see the bottom of the panini was burnt but the properly toasted/grilled side was facing up, but this was the underside. The bartender was cheerful, but when shown the "Burnini" I was asked if I want to have another one made, at that point I said "no" I'm not wsiting that long for another one and had her give me a fork so I could peel off the underside bread so I could at least eat some lunch. Review of sliders = not good, review for returning to this locarion, "absolutely not". Maybe a new chef is in order for...