Original Eagle Pizza — Restaurant in Haverford Township

Iv been eating eagle pizza since I was in high school I am now forty, the last 2 times have been the worst iv ever had anywhere!! The first time last month I ordered a xl pizza with extra cheese, when it arrived all the cheese was in the corner of the box when I called eagle they apologized and ramade it and it was good, now tonite I ordered like every weekend and I wanted eagle this time, so I ordered the same and this time...smh....it was thin as the box, we took off the tiny bit of cheese and compared the pizza to my credit card and they matched, look at the picture!!! They charged $22 bucks ended up 30 with tip for thin as paper pizza, Then I called 9 times to let them know about it and that I don't want anything back I'm done and nobody would answer, as an 24yr customer I feel ripped off, if you want good pizza go anywhere but here, toni ronis,crust, hell even 7 eleven has better...

For me, a good pizza has to have a great sauce. Not the kind that tastes like it came out of one of the gallon tin cans. It has to have zest and good seasoning. And the cheese has to have flavor. Eagle excels at both. I can tell when eating it that the cheese isn't the cheapest they could find. My favorite pie here is getting the extra large (a little thinner crust than the large pie) with extra sauce, and I have them make it 'golden brown' on top. (Keeps the cheese in place with all the extra sauce.) It has yet to disappoint me over the 10 years I've been getting it. Pie is full of flavor. We never have leftovers it is so good. It isn't the cheapest pie in Havertown, but made the way I describe above, it will be one of your top "go to" pizza's when you want something better than the run of the mill stuff other places sell on Darby Rd or West Chester Pike. Been a customer...

We were frequent customers in the 90’s until we left the area in 2000. Always thought highly of the pizza and when I found myself in the area yesterday, I ordered a XLarge 1/2 sausage, 1/2 pepperoni. The robust flavor was as remembered but we found the crust lacking in that it is so very thin compared to what we enjoyed years earlier. Not sure if that was a function of the XLarge size introduced after we left the area or if there was an intentional change to all pizza offerings. On balance, it was good but we all agreed last night that it was not the “Original” Eagle pizza we remembered. Perhaps I’ll try a smaller size given a future...