All Star Bagel & Grill of Forked River — Restaurant in Lacey Township

We put in an order for pickup on a Sunday morning. They called me back to let me know they had run out of some of the flavors we wanted. No big deal. Picked up the order, got it home, and it was missing the cream cheese. Called them back, they apologized and we went back to the store. They were clearly super busy and stressed but were absolutely polite, apologized for the missing part of the order, gave us extra to make up for it, and the bagels were awesome. Warm, soft, fresh from the oven, the cream cheese was great, we will be going back in the...

I was there on a Sunday. Very busy as usual. With a packed house the staff was still very pleasant and professional. I also lost my debit card in or around the establishment. The staff took the time to watch the camera and see if I had dropped my card inside the stor. Unfortunately it was not recovered. However even tho they were closing, busy, behind, and whooped from a long day my experience was absolutely top knock. I've never been more pleasant with a staff response to not only my order and food but my personal things being lost....

Went to All Star after first going and leaving the ridiculous line of a popular bagel place that was sold out of the three types of bagels we wanted. Our group ordered a baker’s dozen of bagels of various types (egg everything, egg, sesame, chocolate chip, cinnamon raisin. All bagels were very good and perfect sized and flavored. This place should be more crowded- I hope the word gets out of this bagel stop. Looking forward to ordering other breakfast options...