Sicilia Pizza & Subs — Restaurant in Mount Holly Springs

We purchased " subs" for a picnic. My husband had a cheeseburger sub and he said it was loaded. He ordered a pizza sub for me and what I got was nothing short of terrible. It seemed like they took a sub roll and smashed it down into a very thin crust like a flatbread, put sauce and cheese on it and baked it in the oven. Most of it was rock hard so I ate about half. Most of the edges and a lot of the back was burnt and I was not able to eat it. I'm not sure why they could not simply make a pizza sub by leaving the roll as it was, putting the sauce and cheese on it and heating it. I often get pizza subs from other restaurants and I've never had it served like this. When my husband went to place the order the lady at the counter seemed to not understand what he wanted or what even came on the sub when he was simply ordering off the menu. Someone came out from the back to help. Not a...

They close at 8 PM!! Not 8:30! We showed up a few minutes before close and they still made us a pizza. Most restaurants would have locked the door as we approached. Very pleased with how our visit turned out. We got the white pizza with no toppings to go. It was delicious. The crust had good flavor and was cooked to perfection. They have quite the menu so we can't wait to get back there and try the subs, bolis and all of the specials they had. I asked how long they have been open and they said 40 years if I remember correctly. I love family owned restaurants and I could tell the owner is very humble and knows he has a great establishment. The decor for Christmas really put us in the mood to eat in house but unfortunately there wasn't time. So we will definitly be back to try some more goodies and have a nice, relaxed...

I used to hate Sicilia's. The choice pizza place was Italian Taxi for the longest time. However, recently the roles have switched. Italian Taxi takes forever to make you food and then its an average quality.

Sicilia's staff are nice and are always smiling. They have about 10 or so tables you can sit and eat, plus a TV which is nice. However you have to watch what they're watching, but it's never boring stuff.

The food quality is very good as well. Dough is always done just right, it's never over cooked or under cooked. The Sauce has good consistency and tastes great. The cheese and other toppings are fresh and you can tell.

I hardly ever give 5 stars, as everything needs improvement. I would say improve the parking lot. Because it's a hassle...