New Story Coffee House — Restaurant in Mount Pleasant Township

During a somber weekend visit for my fiancee's grandmother's funeral, we stumbled upon New Story Coffee House, and it turned out to be a true silver lining in a difficult time. We've frequented Mt. Pleasant on multiple occasions over the years, always lamenting the absence of quality coffee shops. The options were limited to gas station brews or the recent Dunkin'. However, New Story Coffee House has single-handedly changed the coffee game in this town.

Rachel and Keith, the heart and soul of this cozy haven, made us feel right at home. Their warm and welcoming demeanor provided a glimmer of solace amidst our trying circumstances. Their understanding and kindness were deeply appreciated, and it made our visit feel like we were among friends.

Now, let's talk about the coffee – the true star of the show. Mt. Pleasant was long devoid of a place to savor expertly crafted espresso-based drinks. That is, until New Story Coffee House stepped in. The coffee here is nothing short of excellent. Every sip is a testament to their dedication to the craft. The rich aroma, the perfectly pulled shots, and the velvety steamed milk all come together harmoniously.

To Rachel and Keith, your dedication to quality, your warmth, and your inviting coffee house have left an indelible mark on us. We'll definitely be back whenever we're in town, and we encourage everyone to support this wonderful establishment. A cup of their exceptional coffee is more than a beverage; it's a sip of comfort and a testament to the power of community coming together. I look forward to see how the space/place evolves with more seating, food options, etc.!

Thank you, New Story Coffee House, for giving us a new reason to smile in...

It's a really nice cozy coffee house. They are new but great. They take the time out to really appreciate the brew of coffee. Honestly, New Story Coffee House is the place you need to stop into if you visit Mt. Pleasant. They legit take their time into making sure the coffee is perfect. So everytime you do go back, because you will go back, your type of drink will be made exactly the same way everytime. It will be fantastic, you will get excellent service, and you will have the best place locally to get your coffee.

They help out in the community as well. They donated a ton of coffee to the helpers of that Laurelville Retreat Center fire cleanup. Just really great people.

You might have a routine of stopping at Dunkin donuts or somewhere else every morning to get your drink, but you need to change it up and give this place a shot. They are fantastic people who simply enjoy the art of a brew. They have great prices and a very good variety of drinks as well.

Don't hesitate into going to this place. Just go and you won't regret it. You'll just wish they've been around your entire life so you're coffee needs would've...

My only regret is i can't live next to this real style coffee house. It looks like a salon house after you leave town so hard to find but a gem. Right after the train tracks and then another hill and as you decend it is on the right. Heard them in the back cleaning when i came in wed afternoon. They even chatted me up even though i only had a custom made beautiful latte with scratch syrup. Try it out and give them money. It is so good and i was so thrilled to see the barista making it with care. Seriously best place to get a coffee maybe ever. It is like someone is serving you in their...