Millie's Pizza — Restaurant in New Buffalo

Very disappointed with the service we received this evening. We typically really enjoy this place but tonight's experience left us questioning if we'll ever return. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and a order of mozzarella sticks. Was charged $34.97 and when my fiance returned home, he questioned why it was so much? Our mozzarella sticks were also burnt, cold and thrown in a brown paper bag with no sauce. No complaints with the pizza. I called to question the total charged and the girl on the phone was very unprofessional, unapologetic and quite rude. Was told we were overcharged after asking how much both items cost and a unknown amount would be refunded back onto our card, then hung up on without another word. I called back and was told when "he" gets time, "he" would refund the card and rushed off the phone before I could speak. I then called back again to ask that "he" please call me when "he" has time. This is awful customer service. If I do receive a phone call back and things are made right, I will...

We ordered a large meat lovers pizza and 1 Italian sub and 1 cheeseburger sub. The delivery was faster than expected and I did not have the pizza but my son in law said it was awesome. I had the cheeseburger sub. 1st the hamburger patties were amazing tender and juicy,2nd the roll hand made and soft and delicious. This roll did NOT come out of a bag. The sub was well put together and perfectly portioned additional toppings. I have rarely enjoyed one more. The delivery driver was prompt and polite, my sub was still warm . I highly recommend this restaurant. Great job all around...

We have never actually eaten inside Millie’s but it’s a cute little old house right off the highway. Their dough is fantastic, we haven’t had a single thing we haven’t liked from here. But let me just say the absolute joy it brings me that they DELIVER. We live near the ferry boat campground which is 10 minutes away and it always arrives within the time (or sooner) provided. The ONLY thing I’d like to say is they don’t provide bread with salad which is just probably something I’m trained to think from other pizza shopped but no reason to take away a star....