The Speakeasy — Restaurant in Newburg

Ordered carry out, 2 pizzas and fries. The woman who took the order on the phone made it seem like it was a big hassle. I asked to order a deep dish pizza was told they don't do that on Fridays. Asked about rueben rolls, they don't have them. When I said okay ill just have a sausage and cheese pizza she said it's going to take an hour, I said no problem, it just turned 5pm and I was ordering early for dinner. Then I added another pizza...a pepperoni and cheese...now she said an hour and 20 minutes. Then when I ordered fries she reminded me again that it would be over an hour at least. As she had already said this several times, it just felt like she was discouraging me from ordering. I get it's busy on a Friday but if you want customers don't make them feel like it's a hassle for you to put an order in. Every restaurant is busy on a Friday night. So I waited for a hour to pick up and my pizzas were cold when I brought them home...three minutes away. So they likely sat awhile.under their countertop heat lamp in cardboard boxes. They were thin, very greasy (with puddles of liquid grease under the pizza). Each slice of the sausage pizza had one chunk of sausage. They go a bit heavy handed with oregano sprinkled on the top, which some people may like. The fries also have seasoning on them. The woman who was behind the bar at pick up was obviously irritated by everything. I get people have bad days. I'm just not coming back. Feel I wasted 45.00 on poor...

Tom , Paul , and I wat at your place tonight . Looking forward to a fantastic ruben sandwich . I called last week and qas told that the ruben was back on the menue. The Bill was $90.00. For 3 rubens Unsatisfactory food.Terrable Ruben. NOT what it was before. Cook denied that it was only sliced thin. Not interested in the customers response. Terable lie. He only argued. Cold food and cheese not even melded. Ordered onion rings and got discusting cold onion pedals. Too bad. Should have never changed your great Main drawing smoked ruben and brisket sandwich. If there wasn't enough profit just increase the price of the meal. Too bad to ruin your reputation. Nice atmosphere and good bartender.

thatde? it was itit was .cook denied it...

We ordered the Jimmy the Greek pizza, mozzarella sticks, and garlic bread with cheese for pick up. We hadn’t ordered any food there in quite a while, not for any particular reason just had kind of forgotten about the place. When we pulled up to pick up our order, they let us know that they threw in some chocolate chip cookies, which I thought was really sweet. That pizza was freaking amazing! The crust is the best crust I think I’ve ever had on a pizza. I not a pizza crust person and it was literally one of my favorite parts! The mozzarella sticks had Parmesan cheese on them. The garlic bread was delicious and the cookies were an unexpected but delicious treat. We will be back.Excellent food...