Katie's Pies — Restaurant in Nicoma Park

It’s taken me a while to actually post a review for Katie’s Pies, but the longer I think about it the more I want people to know.

I’m usually all about local industry, but I was severely disappointed with our wedding cake I paid Katie hundreds of dollars to make.

I am including a picture to show that it was leaning and melting before the wedding even started. Not just the reception, the entire ceremony. She asked me to see the cake before the ceremony and before I paid, and I did, and was honestly so disappointed by it when I saw it. But by the time it was on the table and I was looking at it, it was going to be too late to get another cake.

My colors were rose gold, gold, and cream. These colors do not match what I requested. The pink was almost lavender. The gold was brassy. The cream was white.

I’m also including a picture of our groom’s cake. I bought the topper that was a wife dragging a groom from fishing. But she literally included Nemo and Dory fish like it was a cartoon cake, which I didn’t request. It felt like a joke. And the makeshift “dock” she says she made, was also melting and falling apart before the reception even started.

This was the happiest day of my life and I did not let her cakes ruin it. But it was a damper on the day and something I wish I could back and hire someone else for.

I see her recommended a lot, and I’m sure her pies and cupcakes are great. But I would not hire Katie or recommend her to anyone that wanted a wedding cake or...

Katie's is one of Eastern Oklahoma County's hidden gems. Tucked off 23rd street, she features breakfast items, cookies and other sweet concoctions, and even snowconrs in the summer, which are all fantastic.

My personal favorites are the chocolate chip cookies (with chocolate dipped backs and chocolate drizzled lines over them) and the no-bake chocolate peanut butter cookies (with peanut butter drizzle on top). My husband loves the peach ring snowcones.

I really haven't had much of anything i didn't like there. I even got my birthday (turtle cheese)cake from her this last year and it was totally yum!!!

I highly recommend Katie and her great crew for your next sweet fix when you're in the area, or even if you're not. It's worth the drive from anywhere in the metro OKC area!!! Msybe even further!!

Please stop by this woman owned and operated jewel. If you can, follow her Facebook page to keep updated on sll her daily goodies. Your tummy will definitely thank you and keep you coming back for more.

Tell her Kat sent ya. You won't get a discount or anything, but you'll remind her that some of her frequent customers are supporting her here on Google.

Have a tasty day!!!

PS: forgot to mention her Dubai strawberry cups and more. Totally amazing and oh do boujee!! Don't forget...

DO NOT GO HERE.

We ordered a small cake from here for a birthday. We arranged to pick it up on Friday after 12:00. When we got there at 2:30 they were confused. After looking through their papers they had the pick-up day as Saturday. They said they were currently working on Friday’s’ orders and would have it done at 3:30. We drove 15 minutes back home and had to go back an hour later. When we returned at 4:00 the baker wasn’t there. The 2 ladies that were got our cake for us. When we looked at it we found the birthday message that was supposed to be on top was not there. At that moment the baker walked in the back door and was told by the young lady what was happening. With no words or acknowledgment to me or the mistake she took the cake behind the counter. After a minute or so she asked to verify the spelling of the message on top. Once she finished she walked out from behind the counter with the cake. She opened the top and showed me the message. I verified it was correct and said thank you. She just gave me a look, still didn’t say a word and walked behind the counter.

The customer service here is atrocious especially after the mistakes that they made.

As for the cake itself. The edges were hard and felt a little burnt.

I do not recommend this place and will never...