Bartolo's Pizza — Restaurant in North Londonderry Township

If you like Sweet Sauce this is the absolute best place to go in the neighborhood. We like sweet, so we go there on occasion. The only downfall I have noticed (over the past 3 years) is that they are not very friendly at all. So, if you you can look beyond that and just get your stuff and leave and don't want to feel invited or welcomed, then the sweet sauce is worth it alone. If you want friendliness then you'll want to go elsewhere in town. I won't bash them or offer the competitors in town (you can look my other 'local guide" reviews up for that). However, friendliness is certainty not a strong suit for Bartolo's and I have been hopeful for years that it would get better, it...

Great Staten Island Italian meals. I ‘m from Joisey and know great Napolitano flavor. First enjoyed Bartolo's in 1984 in Lititz. Never stopped coming back.

Stopped by July 6, 2024 for a sausage and peppers and onions sub with shredded mozzarella and lotsa sauce on top. Wife had a delicious tuna salad w/ 1/2 loaf of fresh each day home made bread. This first generation Italian family restaurant not only respects each and every customer , they serve specialties highlighting Bartolo’s unique homemade pasta sauce and loaves of bread 🥖.

From Bartolo to Anthony and Joseph, father to sons, the business is 45 years old this...

Palmyra has an abundance of three things: banks, churches, and pizza shops. I can't tell you about the first two, but of the 20 others in town and in the surrounding area, Bartolo's is by far the best pizza place around. I've had a lot of pizza in my lifetime and nothing comes close to a plain cheese pizza from Bartolo's. The recipe has been the same during my pizza-going experiences and the taste is super consistent. The dough, cheese, and sauce are sublime, but the sauce, in particular, is really special and has a bit of sweetness to it. Seriously. Don't listen to the naysayers, Palmyra's best pizza place...