Teddy's Old Lyme Pizza Palace — Restaurant in Old Lyme

Teddy's has the best rice pudding in the USA. I have traveled all over the US and I have not found a recipe that even comes close. Teddy's also has great pizza. The crust is not too thin and not too thick. The house special pizza is completely covered with the toppings. There is an excellent quality of mozzarella cheese on the pizza, as well. It does not burn. We had their Friday prime rib for the first time. Very good. I have also had the stuffed peppers, the fish and chips, (this is my friend's favorite restaurant for fish and chips)many sandwiches - all are great. When we come to the Connecticut shore, Teddy's is always one...

Very tasty and very fresh food. Quite a varied menu with gluten-free alternatives. Service was attentive. Niantic clam chowder was superb, although more salt than necessary, especially as it already had bacon. lump crab cake appetizer was delicious, although tiny. Dinner salad with walnuts and Granny Smith, apples was exceptional, which is a maple vinaigrette was excellent plus the freshest of ingredients. If the waitstaff offers, any alternatives, such as “ice cream or whipped cream?“ be sure to ask for the price. Aternatives can cost more. Nevertheless, the blueberry pie was out...

A great little sit down outside on picnic table or takeout restaurant! I almost drove right past it, but so glad we spotted it. The woman at the window was super friendly and told us a little history of the place. The prices were reasonable and the serving size adequate. We only got onion rings this time, which were so good thick, juicy onions, surrounded by a great batter, freshly made and no long wait but we'll be back for pizza next time for sure! Judging by the aroma wafting out the window, I know it's...