Dominick's Pizza — Restaurant in Peapack-Gladstone

Made a commute to Bedminster for Burnt Mills Cider only to find out their food truck of pizza wasn’t going to be in due to weather. My cousin and I decided to get some pizza local to the cider place and we came across Dominick’s Pizza. Let me tell you, the best BBQ chicken pizza HANDS DOWN. We ordered a medium (wish we ordered a large because it was so good!!) half BBQ chicken and half pepperoni with mushrooms and the pizza was so tasty, you could tell it was made with love and fresh ingredients! I will definitely be making the hike back just to come and eat their pizza! Totally recommend to everyone, you will...

This pizza is average at best. Pretty bland, in my opinion, especially compared to other local options. The staff was also rude and only engaged with my husband and I minimally. We never even confirmed that we actually wanted to order before he had started putting slices in the oven for us. At that point, we felt obligated to order. So we did. And still, even after that, the staff just entirely ignored us. Didn’t even speak to us as we checked out, didn’t even verbally tell us that our food was ready. Just put it on the counter and stared at us. I won’t be going back. I prefer Gladstone Market by...

Went to get 2 slice of pizza today, the only 2 old slices i could see behind the window. You could see they were from probably 3 days earlier. The person behind was very arrogant asking me if i had cash although 2 slices and soda was just under $10. He happily said he could not give me the slices as i didnt have any cash. I didnt see any sign that says cash only under $10. Despite old pizza, the arrogance of the person behind made me write this review. I would nt recommend this at...