Mancuso's Restaurant — Restaurant in Reynoldsville

This is hard for me, because 1. I hate being negative 2. We love pizza.

If there was a competition for the worst pizza restaurant in America... this would be a calling for Gordon Ramsey himself.

I will start with the positives. We loved the puzzles on the walls in the dining room. It made the wait pleasurable, as we looked at time capsules all around us.

From the beginning- our waitress walked over and looked at us and asked if we needed menus- she had earbuds in, and I thought it was for service communication- later, when we had to yell to get her attention, we found that to be false.

The pizza crust was so hard that I "tinged" the crust off of my plate without bending or cracking it... it was more like a thick cracker. The sauce was super heavy. We ended up eating the cheese and toppings off the pizza and left the crusts. When we asked for a box to take the pizza home (to try not to be rude), the waitress said "I'll get you a small box, you can stack the pieces"... the pizza was still warm at that time, but after waiting 40 minutes for the pizza to be made, we weren't planning to sit and wait for it to cool down.

The atmosphere had us super excited. If we wanted to go to a slower bar, get some beers and fried foods, this would have been great- the bar parons all seemed very pleased with their service and satisfied. The pizza part of the restaurant.... well.... this one was a flop.

We may go back and try other foods. My hope is that the pizza is just meh, and the other food is great-...

If you’re in town and ordering this for delivery do not order from this restaurant. My was order wasn’t delivered and they are refusing to refund me the money even though I never got the food. I should note, I ordered it on their website not through a third-party like DoorDash. But the receptionist (Who is clearly annoyed with me the customer), explain to me that once DoorDash gets it it’s not their problem anymore. Be very very very careful if you’re going to order delivery from this restaurant, I don’t trust them and I would never order from them again.

Even if the food is as good as all of these reviews claim it to be, why spend money on a place that isn’t going to give you any food. Do not order delivery from...

Long wait (hour+) for a stale crust pizza. I don't mind a wait for fresh food and I figured it was going to be fantastic since it was taking so long. Sauce and pepperoni were good, but I couldn't get past the crust that tasted like it came out of a frozen pizza box. Drinks were okay. Service was fine. If they would just make a fresh dough, it would be a really good pizza. It's a waste of good-tasting toppings put...