Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream — Restaurant in Sandwich

Sweet Caroline’s was better… it’s cash only and most people don’t carry cash on them anymore. I order a simple chocolate soft serve and it took 15 minutes to come out!!!! And there was only a family of four there!! It’s a bunch of kids messing around now trying to run an Ice cream shop. Also don’t listen to the online website because it says they’re open till 10 but they really close at 9. I’m sad to say that my overall experience here was horrible. Don’t bother wasting your time let alone...

Whether your vacationing on Cape cod or a resident, I highly recommend their peanut butter Oreo. The PBO flavor is rich with Oreos, peanut butter & sweet cream. Put all that together and I believe it's the best PBO on Cape cod. A couple of my other favorite flavors are coffee oreo, grape nut and chocolate peanut butter. On a final note, peanut butter Oreo is a featured flavor and you might want to call first to make sure...

The ice cream is soooooo good, but damn is that service slow. Waited 25 minutes from getting in line to eating ice cream, and their was only 2 people in front of me. Also, they are a cash only business with no ATM... Does that make any sense? If I didnt drive 25 minutes for their ice cream I would have just left. Had to drive to stop and shop down the road. All that aside, best ice cream...