American Pie Company — Restaurant in Sherman

American Pie Company in Connecticut is a popular destination known for its delicious pies and cozy atmosphere. Here are some key points based on customer reviews:

Quality and Taste The pies at American Pie Company are highly praised for their quality and taste. Customers frequently mention the flaky crusts and flavorful fillings. Both sweet and savory pies receive acclaim, with favorites often including apple, blueberry, chicken pot pie, and quiche.

Variety The bakery offers a wide variety of pies, catering to different tastes and preferences. Seasonal specials and a rotating selection ensure that there is always something new to try.

Ingredients Reviewers appreciate the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients. The emphasis on locally sourced produce and homemade recipes adds to the appeal and authenticity of the pies.

Ambiance The atmosphere at American Pie Company is described as warm and inviting. The rustic, homey decor makes it a comfortable place to enjoy a meal or a slice of pie with coffee. It's a great spot for both casual visits and special occasions.

Service The service is frequently noted for being friendly and efficient. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu and often goes out of their way to make customers feel welcome and satisfied.

Value While some find the prices a bit on the higher side, most agree that the quality and portion sizes justify the cost. The pies are considered a good value for the craftsmanship and ingredients involved.

Community Engagement The bakery is known for its community involvement, often participating in local events and supporting local causes. This engagement adds to its charm and connection with the community.

Accessibility Conveniently located, American Pie Company is easily accessible, with parking available. It's a popular stop for both locals and visitors exploring the area.

🥧American Pie Company is highly regarded for its delicious, high-quality pies, welcoming atmosphere, and friendly service, making it a beloved spot in Connecticut for pie lovers and anyone looking for a delightful...

An absolute 5 star gem!!! Drove up from NYC today for a quick day trip in the area, and after reading the Google reviews about this eaterie/bakery - we decided to try it out!!

There's plenty of outdoor and indoor seating, and we were lucky enough to get a table outside. Our server was Morgan, and she was amazing! Funny, welcoming, made excellent food, drink,, and dessert recommendations - and made our dining experience a evening to remember.

Items we ordered:

Red Sangria and Mimosa (with Pineapple Juice and Grenandine) - both drinks were fruity yet had a nice kick of liquor.

Veggie Minestrone Soup and Split Pea Soup - Absolutely delicious (they also sell frozen quarts of the soup which you can take home).

Rodeo Burger, Chicken Fajita, and California Melt - all were excellent and tasty, and great size portions. Their potato salad which is served as a side dish for their burgers and sandwiches was also very good.

Key Lime Pie and Pumpkin Whoopi Pie - Super yummy, fresh, and sweetly delicious.

Morgan made us feel like we were part of the family there, the food and drinks were great, the prices were excellent - and we will definitely visit again very soon! Apparently the brunch is something to be enjoyed and savored, so we will visit again very soon!!

THANK YOU FOR A BEAUTIFUL DINING EXPERIENCE!

P.S. - Bought their Apple Pie (they sell pies to take home too) and I'm eating it now as I write this, and it is...

UPSIDE: Been to the restaurant and bakery multiple times. Every time I’ve gone to the restaurant and tried new things, everything was excellent! Never had a bad meal there. The chicken pot pies that you can buy to cook at home are delicious (a bit heavy on the cream side though- so beware if you have sensitivity lol).

The bakery has amazingggggg pies!!! Raspberry peach is the best! All of them a awesome. Best pies I’ve had in a long time.

DOWNSIDE: Do NOT, I repeat, do NOT bother getting their takeout pizza. Sorry to say- but it was probably the worst I’ve ever tasted in my life (and I’m from New York and have eaten a LOT of pizzas in my lifetime haha). LOVE the pies and restaurant- but stay away from the pizza. Not their forte. Also avoid their baked goods that aren’t pie-related. I hate saying this since I love the place- but I’m an avid baker and dessert lover and I’ve tried their cake/cupcakes and dessert bars a couple times and each time I was very disappointed. The lemon bar was probably a recent one I tried that was horrid. Had barely any lemon flavor and tasted like food that sat in the fridge too long and soaked up the flavors from the Mexican take-out you got the night before (NOT even kidding). It tasted so bad. Also tried the carrot cake and was not impressed. Stick to the dessert pies and...