Bentino's Pizza — Restaurant in Silvercreek Township

Came here with friends for what was supposed to be a quick food stop. We ordered a single 8” pizza, cheese bacon fries, and cheesy garlic bread. Simple enough, right? We thought so too.

The server was polite and welcoming, promising to bring waters while we waited—reasonable, since we were all parched. But somehow, it took forty minutes to receive four cups of ice water.

An hour and a half passed before the pizza and fries finally arrived. The garlic bread? Never showed. We waited even longer, freezing the entire time thanks to the door being propped open and the cold air coming in.

After being ignored and chilled, we walked out, still without the bread we paid for. Absolutely...

Had dinner at the Jamestown Bentino’s Sunday, January 12, 2025. Ordered 2 large (16” diameter) pizzas and started with a pound of boneless chicken wings. The pizzas were a thin crust pepperoni and a regular crust with sausage and banana peppers. The thin crust pepperoni was good. A 12” inner diameter of the regular crust sausage banana pepper pizza was mushy and doughy. My son thinks they used frozen sausage which would explain the mushy and doughy part. The boneless wings were average at best and over-priced. The server charged $1 for a thimble of buffalo sauce that i used for the dry rub wings. The overall experience was...

We happened upon this place while out exploring and man am I so glad we turned around and tried them out! The pizza was PHENOMENAL! We had the greek and margarita pizzas and man... I've never had a margarita pizza that good. The fresh basil really set it off. They had some great seasonal craft beers on tap and a really good bourbon selection for a restaurant that doesn't specialize as a local hot spot bar. We have stopped going to our local pizza places and make the trip to Jamestown whenever we have a hankering now. It's totally...