Godfather's Pizza — Restaurant in Timberville

The pizza my husband and I had was practically un-eatable. We were pretty surprised considering all the reviews of people saying it was the best pizza around! The woman who made our pizza told us it was her first time back at the pizza station, so it might have been that she was a bit rusty making pizzas.

We ordered the Classic Combo, which I would assume would be super flavorful, but the pizza we had was far from flavorful. It tasted like soap. We paid over $17 for 8 slices of pizza, so it's pretty expensive for it to be disappointing.

We've eaten many pizzas in our lifetime, and this was easily the worst pizza we've ever had. It seemed like the quality of their ingredients...

It's pretty good pizza. I like the buttery crust, the toppings are decent, and the price is a little high for my tastes. Of the local pizza joints, Godfathers is probably my fourth favorite. They do have a decent location right by the river, and lots of seating. If you want a nice, crispy, greasy pizza this...

The staff was awesome. I was traveling up I-81 and ordered a pizza. They were nice enough to trust and make the pizza. I made it there at exactly closing time. The owner and his family had my pizza nice and hot. I was so grateful they waited on me. I will try to visit this location when I...