Nicholas Creamery — Restaurant in Tinton Falls

Where do I start??? I ABSOLUTELY LOVE, LOVE , LOVE , LOVE NICHOLAS CREAMERY & it’s EMPLOYEES! EVERYONE IS SO FRIEND, POLOTE, WARM, INVITING & KIND. They always help you with flavors, by allowing you to sample to help make your decision on which flavor to get much easier, since alllll their flavors sounds and look so yummy 🤤! The store is immaculately clean. It smells good. It so inviting when you walk in and it makes you want to buy from there. The flavors they have are to die for. My 3 favorites are RAINBOWS 🌈 & CLOUDS ☁️, BROWN SUGAR COOKIE DOUGH & COOKIES 🍪 & CREAM. I love 1 hour & 10 minutes away but we drive there allll the time just to get their ice cream. It’s so rich, and flavorful and my Gawdddddd so addicting 😅🤤🤤🤤! When we go there we buy 6 pints at a time and put it in a cooler bag and bring it back home. I wish they would open up more locations, especially near me, because I don’t eat any other ice cream but there’s. The last time we went JACK N helped us and he was such an angel. I wish every employee at all stores could exude his mannerism and kindness. Thank you JACK. I highly recommend this creamery if you’re in the area. I have attached some videos and photos of the flavors and inside the store. I hope this helps anyones decision looking for some yummy...

I normally go to the one in Fair Haven location but decided to check out the Tinton Falls location. Everything seemed normal. Love everything there is to this company. Love their small batch ice cream flavors. My favorite is the brown sugar cookie dough and peanutbutterpalooza. The only reason this location gets only 3 stars is due to the portion size that was scooped out. The two customers that were being served before my party ordered medium sized cups and when the next server asked for my order I had also ordered 2 medium sized cups. Moving along to check out my ice cream cups were brought to the check out area, the customers before me are currently paying and i see the difference in ice cream in my cups vs theirs. Wow... seems I was missing an entire scoop of ice cream... Long story short, the ice cream servers should truly be aware of how much goes into the different sizes. I think I'll just keep going to the Fair Haven...

Went there on a Thursday night and there was a pretty good line to be served, which to me, it wasn't much of an issue. The employees were kind and understanding from what I observed. I ordered a Cookies and Cream milkshake which is my go-to at most ice cream parlors. It was around 7-8 bucks and I enjoyed every sip of it. Tons of ice cream options for scoops. The waffle cones are very tempting as you can smell them the closer you get to the counter. They also have ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches, water etc. Can't wait to visit again.

Note: if you are mildly lactose intolerant like myself who, on occasion, have trouble with dairy... this will definitely hit you later...