The Beach Club at Gurney's Montauk — Restaurant in Town of East Hampton

Was so excited to return to Gurneys this summer, we were enjoying the music and vibe. Ordered chicken tenders and a lobster roll. After 45 minutes we were served RAW AND FROZEN chicken tenders. We discovered this after biting into the tenders. We opened up the rest and they were also raw and frozen. Ridiculous how such an expensive place can have the audacity to serve frozen and raw food after waiting for 45 minutes. We felt so sick and gross the entire ride home. Absolutely disgusted. So much for quality control… will not be returning because of this experience & it’s a shame because they opened up a new restaurant at the resort we wanted to try. Unacceptable for this to happen at an establishment like gurneys, also saw someone else posting about getting raw chicken...

Great beach at Gurneys. Went there a lot over my stay. Had a Cabana, which was set up really nice. Service was good, but the servers didn't come by that often. The servers probably came once every two hours, but you can go up to the bar and ask for things if you need something (drinks, food, sunscreen, etc.). Food was ehh (definitely frozen), but I was there for the beach. Too be honest, I recommend just walking down and getting yourself a beach chair and umbrella, and that should work. Cabana is good if you have a large group or want to have a few couches. Overall, the beach was nice,...

Gorgeous setting. Beach was empty. Mostly private homes. Rooms. Simple , clean comfortable. On the expensive side. But well worth it..Food also excellent but pricey. Had problem with my land line phone. Management fixed it. Immediately. And compensated me very fairly for the inconvenience. Very quiet and relaxing 😌 . Has excellent pool , restaurants; and beach. Spa closed for renovations. Would highly recommend. Looking forward to returning soon. A yell out to the Manager, Josh. Who was phenomenal in dealing with my minor phone...