Steener's Pub — Restaurant in Town of Ellery

My husband and I stopped in at Steener's Pub today for lunch - our first time - and were very pleasantly surprised. I had the deep fried mushrooms and highly recommend them. When they first came out I had to ask what they were because they looked more like large deep fried corn muffins than 'shrooms - they were that big!! I had to cut each one into eighths. And if you like your 'shrooms still 'rare' with just a bit of batter (like I do), then these are also for you. The light batter was flavorful and the accompanying homemade ranch dressing was also delicious with lots of fresh garlic along with a taste of sour cream. I also had the French onion soup - it was good. For my own personal preference, I like more onions - and cut smaller - a touch of Worcestershire, and a bit more broth reduction.

My husband had the French dip with Swiss and found it above and beyond delicious. The waitress actually asked him how he wanted the beef cooked - a first for a roast beef sandwich. The beef was tender and flavorful and the ciabatta roll was fresh and soft. The fries were good - and they had vinegar for them - always a plus. His preference is no peel, but the flavor was good and they were crispy like he likes.

We will definitely be going back - the menu is FULL of tantalizing options that we want to explore. We highly recommend giving Steener's...

It had been a while since I visited the Good Ole Steener's. After noticing the place is consistently rockin by 1:30 p.m. I was convinced it was time for a visit. This past fall, I popped in on the Sunday evening. The Bills almost beat the Tom Brady & the BUCS. There was maybe 10 customers there and i immediately felt at home. Bill's game was on and nobody minded my screaming and shouting for the Bills. The waitress was a sweetheart and Bartender Kerri was great. Ordered mama Steen's chicken Pecan Salad and the flavor balance was amazing. The salad was huge and the flavors contrasted perfectly. For sure 2 full meals in that salad if you have any self discipline for only $14.99. 4 star experience would be 5 stars with a Bills W.

Edit: It's been a few years since my first review, and after many delicious meals I've got to give the food five stars along with great service and a laid back casual atmosphere. I've had several beer battered fish fries, philly cheese steaks, and the huge fried chicken sandwich, to name a few. Most recently, I ordered the broiled haddock supreme, and it was absolutely delicious. Peppers, onions, mushrooms, and cheese atop a large haddock filet. They...

Tried this place for the first time this evening. Having lived in the area for a short while, I noticed it’s popularity. And after reading the menu and looking at pictures I was sure it’d be worth it. I must mention the food was tasty, the house made ranch dressing being a true saving grace. My sole disappointment lies in the ‘Will’s penalty box’ which sounded awesome. The menu which boasts a ‘boatload of fries’ and 3 sauces is rather overstated. The quantity of fries amounted to more of a measly skiff..if that. The sauces, mind you aplenty, we’re not included in quantity as specified or desired. I do not mean to be a stickler over a simple mistake, but if it is going to be described in a certain manner my expectations will coincide. The salad on the other hand was disproportionately large, not a complaint, but a simple notion in noticing there is capacity to not hold back. I only wish they’d done this with the fries, an important staple, lacking in both mass...