Angelina's Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Islip

I dare you,

I dare anyone who is thinking about getting pizza from the same old place for dinner. Try something different, i did and im very happy i did. This place top notch, some people measure a good slice or pie by something fresh made like in those pizza reviews. No i ordered slices that were made and waiting for someone to eat them. Im almost 50 years old and i cannot remember in the past 25 years or more that i had the quality of slice that these were. Almost any decent place can just make a pie, to order that is good…i picked 2 random slices, picked them up at a random time in the day. They were absolutely perfect, no dried out toppings on top, no old tasting slices, i cant wait to try some of their other stuff they make…and unlike the other place in holbrook this place i ordered a specialty slice, a regular slice and 6 garlic knots and it was under $14.00. Same order except i ordered one extra regular slice was $21 and change. The people there are actually really nice people too…so try this...

EDIT: Nice try, Google. This review is for Davincis Pizza, not the current ownership. We tried it a few times, and it is subpar at best. Cracked crust, cheese slides off, and just not as good as it once was. Angelina’s = 2.5 out of 5 stars.

The Absolute best! Right here in the heart of Holbrook! This is arguably the best pizza I've ever had, and it's the only one I eat. Made fresh, always hot and ready, and the sesame seed crust knocks it out of the park! Mario the owner is a super friendly guy, and he knows his stuff! His pizzas are made with TLC and it always comes through in every bite! Plus Mario is just the nicest guy and his staff is great too! They have great specials, and don't miss out on DaVinci's specialty slices, calzones, chicken rolls and especially the spinach and/or pepperoni pinwheels! My oh my, give DaVinci's a try! You'll be so glad you did! Just remember...

I love an old school pizzeria vibe that follows through from owner to slice perfection...and this place has it in spades! From the owner, who knows his pizza, but who also remembers you as a person not just your business and makes you feel like family (hes essentially a bartender but with pizza) to the slices...speaking of which, the grandma slice is amazing, the sauce is my Italian soulmate. If you love garlic the way any sane person should, you need to try it. The grandma Ala vodka is soooo good too. I whole heartedly recommend trying a slice here , but definitely do yourself a favor and try the grandma. That's not to knock the rest, but it's just next level, a thing of absolute beauty to sink your teeth into. He should have named it pizza haven, because there are days and times that a slice here rescues me and calms me down...just saying....