Captain's Table Restaurant — Restaurant in Town of Islip

I am sorry to say I was disappointed. First , I found the upstairs dirty, felt like I was in an attic where a few tables were quickly thrown together. There was no difference between the tiki bar and upstairs menu, food was cold when we got it, bathrooms filthy. This was probably a “shame on me” situation where I thought the caliber of food and overall experience would have been better. Hardly any desserts and no coffee? Can you believe that? I remember going here many years ago and the menu was so much better. Waitress was nice and band was good. For a better ambience. Just stay downstairs...

We held an event for a 17th birthday a few days ago. Everything was perfect. Marybeth is a sweet and doting manager, Elyse was the premier party planner and stayed around well into the event to make sure my daughter was happy, the staff was very friendly and attentive. All the food that my daughter asked for came out great. All the guests, kids and adults, had a great time and loved the venue. They packed us up enough to go boxes to last a few more days! Oh and the sunset that just didn't quit! It made a photo op that lasted for like 20 minutes or more. I highly recommend catering an...

We went there for lunch yesterday. Two things stood out: 1. One of the meals we ordered was fish and chips. Fish cutlet that was served was still frozen inside. When I informed the staff, they gave me 25% off. Ha ha. 2. Meal portions were small with lots of fries. Lobster roll was super small for the price they have. Same with calamari. Price and quantity or quality do not match. In other words, don’t go there if you...