Cultured — Restaurant in Town of Liberty Grove

When the locals point you in a direction, you listen. That's how I found myself diving into these bagels, and let me tell you, it was like a slice of heaven from a different postcode. Coming from NYC, where bagels are a sacred ritual, I was left floored—seriously, someone needs to tell this bagel wizard to set up shop in the Big Apple ASAP.

Now, let's talk about the crew. All-woman powerhouse? Heck yes. From the moment I walked in, it was like catching up with old friends. They weren't just serving bagels; they were dishing out warmth and killer recommendations.

Rainy weekday, line out the door. You heard me right. In a town teeming with quirky spots, this joint's popularity ain't no accident. It's like the real deal in a sea of imitation.

Now, brace yourselves. Breakfast sandwich on an everything bagel, loaded up with shallot and serrano schmear. If flavor had a mic, this sammie just dropped it. I'm talking about that perfect harmony of flavor that makes your taste buds throw a dance party.

I'm already marking my calendar for next year, 'cause a return trip is non-negotiable. Here's to hoping this bagel haven keeps rising and shining. If you're in town, don't even think twice—make a beeline. Your taste buds...

Cultured in Sister Bay is hands down one of the best places to eat in Door County, Wisconsin! Whether you’re looking for a cozy breakfast spot, a delicious lunch café, or a locally owned Door County bakery with fresh, homemade treats, this place has it all. Their breakfast sandwiches, fresh pastries, and artisan coffee are unbeatable.

In just two years, they’ve built one of the most popular bakeries and restaurants in Sister Bay through hard work, passion, and a commitment to high-quality food. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make every visit a great experience.

If you’re visiting Door County or looking for the best bakery in Sister Bay, Cultured should be at the top of your list. Thank you for all the incredible meals—you’ve created something...

I come to Cultured EVERY time I come to visit home from New York! Their kitchen is hustling day in and day out, and they keep the atmosphere lively. I love that they switch up menu options, so it’s like a surprise every time I go. I don’t know what’s in the chocolate chip cookies, but GOD they are some of the best I’ve had.

As a local, seeing a small business boom up here is what we all want, even if it means going and running out of food at times. It happens, and we never go down the route of positing bad reviews to degrade the business. It’s BUSY up here! For people visiting busy Door County… expect it to be busier than you think and plan ahead. That’s what trip planning is for, after all 😊

Thanks team for the amazing eats and being a focal point in...