Mister Mike's Gyros — Restaurant in Town of New Hartford

From the moment I pulled into Mister Mike's Gyros, I knew I was in for something special. The first thing that caught my attention was how immaculately clean the place is — spotless floors, organized counters, and an inviting vibe that immediately sets the tone. Not to mention the super friendly staff who greeted me with warm smiles and genuine hospitality. There’s ample parking too, which is a major plus when you're trying to grab a quick bite during a busy day.

Service was lightning fast without compromising on quality — just the way it should be. And now, on to the real star: the food. I ordered the lamb & beef bowl and it was nothing short of fantastic. The portion size was generous — absolutely packed with flavor, freshness, and sizzling goodness. The ingredients tasted like they were straight from the market that morning, and the seasoning was spot on. Every bite was hearty, savory, and satisfying.

This place nails it — great taste, great service, and great value. It’s the kind of spot that instantly becomes a favorite. I highly recommend Mister Mike's Gyros to anyone who loves fresh Mediterranean flavors served with care and speed. I’ll definitely be coming back, and soon....

Customer service was good. Food was alright.

Lamb bowl should incorporate more rice and sauce as it felt more like a salad topped with lamb.

Overall the taste of the lamb was good, food seamed fresh. (Lettuce, tomatoes olives)

The loaded fries were also not excellent. Not terrible or anything just a preference maybe. The fries should be seasoned, and perhaps a fresh chopped potato or a different bagged fry. Also a lack of sauce so it was overall dry and not very satisfying.

My son’s chicken gyro looked good, chicken was well seasoned but it appeared to lack sauce.

Overall the food was decent, just a lack of rice and sauce I think really makes the difference on if you consider this a go to Greek restaurant. What would set this place apart is if the bowls came dressed and felt more like a bowl with added rice to balance out the lettuce. Would consider choosing to eat here again...

I ordered (take out) 2 chicken gyros and a order of feta fries for me and my son. My first time trying this place and for $32.00, it wasnt that great. The feta fries were awful, they were very dry, no season at all..just what seemed to be old fries with feta thrown on them. I couldn't believe how dry and tasteless the fries were. The gyros, on a scale of 1-10 , I will give a 3...the problem with them was , very messy, hard to pick up ..although I appreciate the abundance of chicken, it just was too much for the pita bread which was wet and soggy. It was a mess. We gave up on eating it like you're suppose to eat a gyro, an just used forks. The taste/seasoning used for the gyro was okay, but the chicken was dry.. I expected the gyros to have more like a (saucey) sauce, but instead it was (watery) Its unfortunate because I really love gyros..and they are hard to find around this...