Georgie's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Newstead

We had been here two years ago and loved the pizza, so went again tonight. Ordered wings and a deep dish pizza, a Pepsi and a beer. The Pepsi was delivered as a Diet Pepsi, so hubby returned it to the bar and got me a regular Pepsi. We were the only customers in the restaurant, a few people sitting at the bar, The food took about an hour and when the pizza was delivered , it was burnt to a crisp on the edges, I mentioned this to the lady who brought it out to us, and her reply was, it’s just the outer cheese, it’s suppose to be like that, it was cut into small squares, not slices, so I took an inside piece, the crusts was paper thin, chewy , like cardboard. It was aweful. The wings were good. No one ever came back to our table to check on us or to see if we needed refills on our drinks. No one ever came with our check, so once again hubby had to go up to the bar to...

Service was super slow and just plain terrible. 4 tables that came in after us all got their drinks and food before us and all we got was a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. The pizza was fantastic but service was horrible, so since the food was good we gave them a second chance. Went back again and service was still terrible. The food was horrible this time around. I did some asking and turns out they fired their original chef. Should have kept him, at least the food would have been good. I will definitely not be returning. You really should at least get your fantastic chef you started with back and hire...

Had a fish fry and it was delicious. Came with fresh cut fries, slaw and Mac salad.

Fish was very fresh and battered just the right amount. I have got their pizza and wing specials several times and have been happy as well. It was nice to try other items !

I clicked 4 for atmosphere. They only have a few tables, some high tops, and we were there on a Friday night so had a wide range of people there for happy hour.

Bartender was our server and she was fantastic! Very attentive managing...