Nick's Pizza & Ice Cream — Restaurant in Town of North Castle

This place survives solely because of its location. There are a lot of landscapers that come through this area to service the rich folk's lawns, and they all cluster at this place for lunch, as well as the connecting deli, which I assume has the same owner due to the shared name. There really isn't anywhere else to go for lunch in the area unless you drive for 10+ minutes, so you can see it's a convenient spot to stop for lunch when it's located in the middle of this rural area.

The sauce on the pizza always has this refrigerator taste, like it's been in the fridge for a long time and reheated over and over. It's also very salty and acidic, there aren't any other noticable flavors. They don't put enough cheese on their pizza, and the cheese they do put on is not the good fresh kind, its the bagged kind with preservatives in it, tastes like budget. Like the sauce, their toppings have the taste and texture of being refrigerated or frozen for a while. Maybe they use the leftovers from the deli next door, who knows? The pizza just gives NY pizza a bad name.

The employees seem like they hate their lives and want to die, and they also want to take you down with them. It's an uncomfortable and unfriendly atmosphere. God help you if you bring any complaints about your food to them. It'd be better to just leave, say nothing, and never go back, unless you care to deal with the vitriol you get from daring to be an...

Nick’s pizza is extremely salty. The salt overpowers the taste and the flavor of the other ingredients. Even my brother who loves salty food complained about the saltiness of the pizza. He encouraged me to write a feedback so that hopefully the nick’s pizzeria will put this factor into consideration and to reduce the amount of salt in their pizza sauce. If you have high blood pressure I strongly discourage you to eat their pizza. Even if you have no health issues like myself, I Warn you to be careful and to not eat much of that pizza. What a shame that as much as the location is convenient for me and my family, we have to choose...

ZERO STARS!!!!! Worst place ever!!! Their milkshakes are trash, they taste watered down and had absolutely no sweetness about them at all. Asked for a refund or different flavor and they guy was completely argumentative about it and would not honor my request. I spent $14 alone on 2 small milkshakes and they both had no flavor. I would not recommend coming to this place at all!! They are money hungry leeches be careful how you spend your hard...