Cafarelli's Pizza & Catering — Restaurant in Town of Rotterdam

I'm an OTR Driver from Florida, any chance I get to test a NY pizza joint I do. This place is in walking walking distance from the truck stop next door. When I came in they were very friendly I looked at a menu and just decided on pizza, The folks that own and work this pizzeria are really nice people. It took about 5 minutes to sort of break the ice but once we did we talked the whole time I was there, really really good people that are here. Now I guess most importantly, the pizza! It was FANTASTIC! I'm not a pizza connoisseur officially, so if I say it was a little light on the sauce it may be only because other pizza places are heavy on the pizza sauce. I thought the pizza that I had was perfect it was exactly what I love and I like to thank the folks again had a great conversation and had great pizza. Sorry about the photos I got a cracked lens...

My Husband and I had lunch here yesterday. We were excited to see it in walking distance from the truck stop and with awesome reviews! The staff is very friendly and welcoming from the young ladies at the counter to the guys in the kitchen cooking! The food is very fresh and cooked to order which is what I loved! We ordered a vegetarian pizza, mozzarella sticks and wings. Everything was fresh on the pizza, the marinara sauce for the mozzarella sticks was delicious and the wings were perfectly cooked. I got hot wings but wish I had gotten mild because they were too hot for me but was still tasty and they are nice sized too! Prices were reasonable fyi. I’m a Floridian and never had NY Pizza until now and it was Great! If ever in this area again I will be sure to visit this establishment and I do...

A truckers dream right next door to the Pilot. Hannah's customer service was spot on. She was pleasant and very courteous. Even though I stepped out with the wrong bag it was no fault of hers. I guess my stomach got ahead of my brain. This pizza was far from norm chain pizza. It was hand tossed with large fresh toppings and delicious! The wings were a nice size cooked to perfection. They were so good the never made it in front of the camera. Appears to be more carry out than dine in since there were only 3 tables. However it was still cute and clean with Sunday football on the tube....