Sunset Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Southeast

La Familia, I am so happy you are in my neighborhood! I just threw a big party for my son’s baptism and my daughter’s birthdays. We ordered a bunch of pies, two wedges, penne vodka, eggplant parmigiana, chicken franchise and chicken cacciatore. Each dish was better than the next. I highly recommend all of the dishes, I wouldn’t really take anything out. MY guests loved the food as well. You can tell they cook their food with love. The flavors are there to prove it! The penne vodka is creamy but not heavy, and eggplant is one of the best I’ve ever had, the chicken cacciatore is a must… the flavor was so so yummy, the chicken franchise was solid, the pizza is the best around, the sauce, bread and cheese ratio was perfect! Thank you la familia for coming here! My family and I will be ordering from you often! Not just for catering but for pizza Fridays too. Owner is very nice too, great...

Sunset Pizzeria Brewster – Solid Spot for a Good Meal

Stopped by Sunset Pizzeria in Brewster and was pleasantly surprised. I ordered the linguine with clam sauce and the orecchiette pasta, and both were really well done.

The linguine had great flavor—light, garlicky, and loaded with fresh clams. It tasted homemade in the best way. The orecchiette was just as good—tender, perfectly cooked, and the sauce had a nice depth to it. You can tell they put care into what they’re serving.

The place has a relaxed vibe and the staff was friendly. It’s not fancy, but it’s the kind of spot where you can sit down, enjoy your food, and leave full and satisfied. I’d...

Horrible experience. I ordered a large pie with extra cheese and when it was delivered it had what could hardly pass as one layer of cheese, it definetly was not extra cheese. I called to let them know and the person I spoke to tried to say they watched the person who made it put an extra layer on. To be fair they offered to make another pie but it wasn't worth the hassle. Wont be getting pizza here anymore. $30 dollars plus $5 tip for cardboard...