Eddie’s at Silver Sands — Restaurant in Town of Southold

Beautiful atmosphere, ambience and excellent food! Came with a party of 4 adults and 4 children. We ordered drinks, margarita pizzas, appetizers, and entrees. But I must say what a process to secure a reservation. The only RESY reservation available was a table of 5 for 2:15pm, online said to call for larger party, but no one answered. So we arrived and what a fiasco!!!! They refused to bring over a few extra chairs, even though there was a collection of extra chairs on the side. We stood around the table waiting for extra chairs while being ignored for over 10 minutes and finally brought one over ourselves. We were completely ignored as other tables were seated. The waitress finally arrived and was so rude.... she walked away saying she refused to serve us because one of our guests expressed frustration with the seating and just wanted a margarita. Finally the manager came over and took care of us. Definitely has room for improvement when it comes to feeling welcome, especially when paying a $500 bill and giving good business as locals. Great place minus hospitality and service. A note to the owners & management; most people would walk away if treated this way in the first 5...

What a refreshing dose of unpretentiousness! Perfect place for a lowkey Sunday supper. Delicious fresh Oysters dressed with gooseberry and house made mignonette. Seared Octopus bathes in taut chilly sauce was memorable. A perfectly Coal fired pizza with guanciale followed. And then the branzino grilled to perfection and topped with mixed herbs and almonds. The squash side was the perfect accompaniment to the fish. (recommended by our waitress) The coffee budino was simple and well made. The coconut foam slathered Grilled pineapple was great although the pineapple felt like it was end of the week… I’d suggest you came fully covered so the meal is not cut short by the...

We've been lucky enough to have dinner twice at Eddie's at Silver Sands and frankly, we can't wait to go back. Let's start with the food: A lot of places on the East End try and slide by with 2star food, knowing there aren't many other places to go. Eddie's, on the other hand, has clearly invested in top quality ingredients and a top-notch chef. The food was incredible. Now the service: I mean, how nice can people get?! Everyone was so sweet, helpful and attentive. Finally, the atmosphere: Hard to go wrong with your feet in soft sand, the waves lapping in front of you on the shore and a gentle summer breeze. If you get the chance....go! You...