Lincoln Pizza — Restaurant in Vineland

Offering an updated review in light of changes here and their local competitors. Im not sure if Lincoln Pizza is under new management or came upon a stronger team but lately they have done a 180 since 2016. They have some of the most competitive prices, high quality pizza and calzones (I cant yet speak to the rest of their food) and their customer service has been MUCH better during my last two visits. Lincoln pizza offers a pizza with a softer, chewier crust (to which I prefer) and they have a fairly sweet pizza sauce (which I also prefer). My only constructive criticism at this point is that I feel like they should offer more than a 2-3 oz container of pizza sauce with their calzone. In a perfect world, I’d like to see that increase to a 8oz container for a small or 16oz container for a large calzone. If not included, it would be cool to have those options for extra sauce associated with dollar amount on the menu AND on food ordering apps like “Slice.”

Thanks for the great meal!

“Decent round pizzas, though a bit salty for my taste. The rest of the food you can easily pass on. Terrible.. Terrible...

Ordered a 3 cheesesteak w/2 liter soda for 29.99 paid 33.04 for it. One w/LTOKM the second hit peppers/sweet peppers LTOKM and the other mayo ketchup. After picking it up and leaving was charged an extra 7 dollars as a seperate transaction on my card the following day. Called and asked for explanation and was told It was for the items added in the instructions. The site doesn’t say anything cost more on the Tuesday special. I only paid online because their phone never works. I didn’t even receive my fried onions or my hot and sweet peppers to top it off. It looks as though they tipped themselves 20% after and now magically the special is up a whole $7 the next day. Returned my money but won’t be going back. It’s not about the 7 or being charged for said Items even though I didn’t receive it. It’s the principle why did you charge me more after I already left and not specify I would be charge more or the amount was...

Really great spot/hole in the wall. I would have missed it honestly but a customer referred them because of their wings.

Walking in they have a deal posted in the wall. 5$ for two plain slices and a fountain drink. Count me in. Great price, hope the pizza is good.

It is. It’s really good. No grease, well balanced. Really crunchy crust. Only downside was that the dough lacked flavor. Personally… I love my crust to taste good. But it’s a minor nitpick. Nothing to avoid this place over.

Also ordered wings… it’s why I came, right?! Garlic Parm. Ooof were they good. Meat was juicy, skin crunchy. Hot and a ton of good flavor. (A bit too much actual garlic made a few bites harder to swallow, but still amazing wings and I will be returning to try other flavors.

Clean store. Fun and friendly staff waiting on me. 9/10 would recommend and return.

Next time I’m in, I’ll be trying a cheese steak and mango...