Wow! This was the first time visiting Mamma Maria Pizza and it way exceeded my expectations, and here is why. Honestly, when we arrived and entered we weren’t sure how the food was going to be. We sat in the middle dining area which is pleasantly very nicely setup with white cloth tables and plenty of seating. Our waiter was fantastic. He was very friendly and did a fantastic job with service. Looking at the menu had me a bit worried because when we see a lot of items listed, it usually is not good - but I was completely mistaken!
We ordered a Margarita pizza as an appetizer and honestly it is one of the best that I have had. The pizza is crispy, perfectly cooked with tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and a good sauce.
The freshly cooked dinner rolls are amazing seasoned perfectly with a bit of garlic.
Then came the salads that are included with the dinner. It was surprisingly large for an included salad and very good too.
Finally came our dinner and it was very very good too, and a good portion of food. I ordered the chicken parmigiana and it was fantastic. The pasta was even cooked al dente, the way I like it.
Overall we had a great experience at this location which we visited because my in-laws recently moved to the area. You have won us over and you have a customer in us! I’m very glad we decided to have dinner at Mamma Maria Pizza. I highly recommend trying them out, you will absolutely not be...
Read moreone of the things i look for wirh a pizza 'joint' is consistency. I have to say after 5 or 6 orders this is the most consistently pleasing pizzareia i have ordered from since moving to Hunterdon County. The mozzarella sticks are always cooked crispy and the cheese.is stringy as one would expect. They are thise thick and fat thumb style sticks and they are prefectly cooked with every.delivery. I have ordered two different topping pizzas generally over the course of a few months and no matter the cheese.is always thick with great sauce and crust. I also had a pizza today with whole sausage half pepperoni and it was great. Crispy crust with a great layer of sauce and cheese plus the added toppings make the total package of a meal. delivery is always speedy. i use the slice app and they are always within the time stated in the app. Give Mamma maria pizza a try you will not be...
Read moreMama Marias used to be good but the last two times we ordered food from there it's been horrible. I ordered a small pepperoni pizza with light sauce, instead they sent me a small pizza with extra sauce and no pepporoni.I also ordered a California chicken cheesesteake and they sent me a roll with grilled chicken and cheese. It didn't have lettuce, tomato, onion and Mayo. It was gross. For the Buffalo chicken salad and all I got was chicken with hardly any lettuce and they put the huge green pitted olives in it and they were gross. If I just wanted Buffalo chicken, I would've just gotten wings. I paid 70.00 dollars for this! Never ever again, I will continue to bring my business to Roman pizza in Oxford. Much better food and much better prices. Mama Maria's is horrible. 0 stars if I...
Read more