Anthony's — Restaurant in Watertown

So many pizza choices in the Watertown/Oakville area, sometimes it's easy to overlook a world class pie. Hadn't gone here for probably over 10 years. Not because it was bad, but back then they only took cash which was a hassle, and I just kind of starting going elsewhere. After driving by the other day and seeing the credit card sign, I decided to give it another try. Turned out to be a good call.

They let you choose your crust type (thin, regular, thick) which is awesome, and I've tried them all...all amazing. They also let you choose how well done you want it from normal to crispy. For this re-visit we opted for a thick crust, crispy pie with a variety of meats. Pie was absolutely amazing. Cooked perfectly, super fresh toppings and a nice tangy sauce. Really delicious. We also went with the antipasto salad which was seriously one of the best pizza place salads we've ever had. We do salads with pizza often and many places just drop the ball there. Anthony's did it right, again.

Overall, its a must try. Even if you're loyal to another, try this place once/once in...

We left before ever ordering. I decided to go here as it was local & also italian. My daughter wanted spaghetti so thought it would be good choice. Come to find out they have no cook top and everything they make is done so by oven. However they did have manicotti & stuffed shells both of which to make would require a cook top to pre cook pasta before stuffing leading me to believe they just buy frozen premade pasta dishes like this then call it their own. Same with sauce how do you cook a italian sauce with no cooktop? Must just serve pre made jarred sauce. We decided to leave and go somewhere else before ordering. However we were charged $5 for 2 iced teas we didnt drink. Now 7-11 down the street charges $0.99 for same fountain drink. Fairly upset over the $5 drink charge my boyfriend was told the police would be called had he not paid it. Give me a break call the police over a $5 charge for iced tea (no alcohol) that is already marked up like 300%. They settled for $2 & we went to a different italian restaurant we were much...

I remember going to Anthony’s once or twice when I was a kid, and after many years of driving by and wanting to go back, my fiancé and I finally made it in. First of all, you totally feel like you’re part of the family when you walk in the door. Everyone was so welcoming, and many members of the same family work at the restaurant, so everyone is down-to-earth and comfortable with one another. We went around Christmas-time when they were serving these gorgeous winter cocktails! We also enjoyed their gigantic antipasto and bruschetta appetizers. Something that really stood out to me was the ability to choose between thin, medium, or thick crust pizza, as well as if you’d like your pizza light baked, medium, or well done. I think it’s a great way to please everyone! The pizzas were incredible. I can’t believe this little gem is in Oakville! The desserts were good too. Looking forward to many trips back...