Waterfront Mary's Bar & Restaurant — Restaurant in Webster

So I have NEVER walk out of any istablishment in my life till tonight. Arrived at 415PM. Ordered a draft beer. NO draft not hooked up. Asked for beer menu, NONE. When bartender explaind, BUD, BUD LIGHT, COORS LIGHT and Corona. None of wich I like. I went with Jameson and coke (12.86). Must get a card for tab. 5 minutes later asking me to cash out. Then said $20 limit on card. Offered a second drink to cover. I sade ok. After 30 minutes my drink wad gone. Nothing but ice. 45 minutes layer still not asked if I want my 2nd drink. Bar teners arguing and cussing out eachother over who should have made a drink another patron had been waiting fir, for far to long. So I asked for a menu after slurping my ice water at this point. Still no offer for my second drink already paid for. After putting the very limited menu down and deciding. NOTHING! 530PM. Stoll nothing! I get up go to the bathroom. Go back to bar. Still NOTHING. Mind you the huy next to me got a 2nd beer. Pizza he ordered. Ate 1/2 of it. Cashed out. Still NOTHING! At 0540 I had enough! I get up walking out leaving my 2nd drink already paid for, still haven't recieved. Never will I ever go back. 45 minute rude out. Terrible service. 45 minute ride home. I get home go to Milford. Red heat. Place is packed. One seat at bar available in 20 minutes!!! I had my draft beer, my HOT FOOD I ordered.

NEVER...

Popped in here tonight for the first time. We walked out back to sit outside by the water. When we did this we said hello to the waitress to be nice but also to inform her we are here since there is no hostess. There was a party of 6, a party of 3 and a party of 1. We sat and waited 20 minutes as the waitress brought the party of 6, 2 drinks at a time (1 in each hand) even though I could see trays available to her. While we sat there 2 more parties had come in after us. After 20 minutes I walked back inside to the bar to order us drinks. Mind you still no menus! When I came back down the waitress was finally taking our drink order (too late) and finally hand us a menu only to find out she had already taken the orders of the 2 parties that came in after us. When we asked her why she would serve them before us she had nothing to say. She stunk! We left and went to point breeze and had a lovely dinner and drinks there and I tipped the waiter a little extra for just simply...

⸻

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 A Heavenly Jewel on the Lake – Waterfront Mary’s

From the moment we turned down Birch Island Road, I knew we were arriving somewhere sacred—and Waterfront Mary’s did not disappoint. The warm welcome, the stunning views of Webster Lake, and the spirit of the place all radiate divine hospitality. ✨🌊

I had the pleasure of meeting the owner—a woman of grace, resilience, and soul. Her presence alone deserves five stars. In a world full of fast service and shallow interactions, Mary’s is a place of depth, care, and community. You can feel the history and the heart in every corner.

The food? Heavenly. The vibe? Iconic. The mission? Alive with purpose. This isn’t just a restaurant. It’s a sanctuary for the hungry, the joyful, and the wandering.

Thank you, Mary, for creating a refuge by the water. This is more than a meal—it’s a moment. And it’s one I’ll treasure. 💫🍽️🙏

— Rachel Joy King (aka Asherah,...