Off the Wolf Supper Club — Restaurant in Winneconne

I had an absolutely terrible experience here. We had a large party but set up a reservation a day prior. We got there 15 minutes before the reservation and they were already ready for us. We sat down and things started off great, until we went to order food. A few of us were disappointed that they ran out of prime rib by 6pm on a Saturday night. No biggie, we found other things to eat. They were also basically out of ribs but they had enough for us. We got our appetizers and salads. Great! Then we ended up waiting for over an hour for our food. We didn't end up getting the main meal until 7:25. They weren't completely packed and busy either.

Then there's the food. I had the medallions and they were cooked great inside. The outside was so salty I could barely stand it. My wife's ribs were tender and fell apart but were so salty that she couldn't eat it. All the dishes amongst the table were basically inedible. My buddy was the first to say something to the server, I also chimed in and I NEVER complain even if I don't like it. Nothing but a "sorry". They screwed up the pricing on my friend's bill with multiple prices for the same item, they "fixed" it and made it cost more.

Normally I'd take a break from an experience like this and give it another chance, but I will not be returning ever again. Which is sad because it's a local place for us and there's not too many options for this type of meal in the area....

We arrived at 4:20, we wanted a few drinks, we asked for a table for 5:30 and they asked us to move to 6 because they had a big table at 5:30. We were seated promptly at 6:00, placed our order and were pretty much forgotten. We got our salads, they ran out of soup and we had to switch or just “forget it”. We had to ask for water, ask for garlic chips, we went to the bar ourselves to get refills on drinks. We don’t said something to the bartender and then the waitress asked if she could get refills. I finalized asked the hostess at 7:25 where our food was and she apologized and referred to a woman I think was the owner who just commented she would “check with the kitchen but you had your soup and salad” really, no apology, she gave me a look like why are you bothering me, I know dinner should be a night out but I have never waited an hour and a half for food...by the way my mashed potatoes were cold but I wasn’t about to send them back. Steak was good, seafood platter was disappointing. I don’t know if I...

We were there Saturday night for the first time. This is such a cute little restaurant located in Winneconne. We were told that they were out of Prime Rib, but not a problem since there is alot to choose from on the menu! All meals come with a salad and soup, the salad was fresh and loaded with all kinds of vegetable. I had the lasagna soup, and it was amazing, my husband had the French onion was excellent, lots of flavor. I had the medallions that were cooked to perfection and were so tender they melted in your mouth. My husband had the ribeye and he said it was one of the best he had ever had. We took some of our meal home to save room for an after-dinner drink! I had the grasshopper that was so big it was stacked on top of the glass and my husband had the brandy alexander.

We had such a great experience with the food and service we can't wait to come back! I highly recommend this supper club, owners definitely know how to run a business and a...