New Egypt Marketplace — Attraction in Plumsted Township

I am new to the area and have been to this location 3 times so far and every visit has been consistent, always greeted with wonderful customer service. The entire staff each visit has gone above and beyond to provide wonderful customer service. The employees at the Deli counter are so kind and truly great at their job, last night I mistakenly ordered the wrong cheese and without a hesitation the kind woman at the deli counter was able to still provide me with the corrected order of cheese even though I had made the mistake . Something like a seemingly quick change was truly so appreciated. In a busy world it is so great to know that she was able to help in such a speedy and pleasant manner but still putting in the care needed. Not only was the employee at the Deli Counter phenomenal another employee at the front of the store saw that the line was starting to build up at the registers. She was proactive and opened up another line to help our her fellow associates and customers. Also, we were unable to find only one item on our grocery list and with the help of the kind gentleman who was stocking the selves was able to find the Tea we were looking for. Again not only is the staff here always so kind and helpful but the store is always clean and the selves are always faced/stocked beautifully. Which is why we will continue to shop at this location. Thank you for the consistent amazing service and job...

I lived in New Egypt for about 8 and a half years, and one thing you could always count on was New Egypt Market. While not the biggest grocery store in the world, they always have what you need. Everything is placed in a spot that makes sense, and not moved around constantly like bigger "name brand" super markets designed to walk you past more impulse buy items. The owner special-ordered items for my family multiple times because of their food allergies. Great people, great market, much preferable to the bigger spots like Shop Rite, etc... I have since moved from the area, and both my wife and I miss the New Egypt Marketplace very much, and long for the simpler, less chaotic...

Smaller portions, higher prices. Things have been changing over the past year and I find I'm at a tipping point between convenience and ROI. It's a shame, as I love the Marketplace otherwise for it's well kept charm and home town feel, but I'm getting priced out.

Staples like Salisbury steak have gone from Oncore 24 oz packages to Hungry Man 16 oz package for a new higher price. The food club items more expensive than the previous brand as well. Items change and the new ones aren't as good.

And while a local market has to charge more due to scale, the new buyers or providers are taking advantage. I'm almost at a point of driving to a bigger market 5 times the distance away...