Open Hearth Lodge — Attraction in Sister Bay

I enjoy Green Bay immensely.

The staff here is extremely nice. I mean, I tend to be talkative, and positive most of the time so that probably helps... but eitherway I can see John the owner and his brother Jordan always chipper.

I was looking for somewhere to stay. This was an emergency visit I needed to get away for health issues. I showed up a little late and Jordan accommodated me at an impressive speed, gave me an amazing price and the room was clean and wonderful....

I was planning on staying here later in the month if things work out with the woman. Animal issues. Cool thing is that John's sister runs Julie's Motel down the street which allows cats, dogs. Wonderful! Right next to Peninsula Park, a nice pizza restaurant, bike rental and shop, and altogether close to Sister Bay and just overall goodies.

Plenty of gas stations too apparently.

Wonderful stay here! Worth jt! Pool! Hot tub! Fire pits. Chill pads, and I swear there's a frisbee golf net in the back.

Barn Owls swoop quieter than.... uhm.... gravity? In the middle of Hwy 72 at like 9 PM's as you check your car.

Recommend this place for families excellent for kids, great log cabin like build as well as a yoda, or baby yoda? Above the entrance fireplace. Hehe.

Too drunk or too lazy to leave? No worries they have a wide selection for you to buy all day and night (I think night).. great selection of wines and beers and such... but other than that... place is worth the money, clean, warm, windows are good too (I always inspect). Excellent hot and cold water (hate low pressure slow systems).

Breakfast in the morning. Everyone here is salt od the earth... at least have been for me. Home away from home.

Oh and thanks for so many pillows!!

So 5/5!...

We stayed at Open Hearth Lodge for two nights. Two adults, 8 year old, and our 8 month old puppy. We wanted a pet friendly property with an indoor pool.

We stayed in room L31. It was a one bedroom apartment. It had a balcony that overlooked the back of the property. Two very large TVs. Large bathroom and shower. King size bed and large whirlpool bath in the bedroom. 6 nice bath towels and other bath linens. We had a sofa bed also. We saw deer outside in the morning. The unit had updated flooring and appliances. Fully stocked kitchen. Very clean thought the entire property!

Free breakfast was good with plentiful options including hot pancakes. Nice breakfast area. Inviting fireplaces throughout, including our apartment.

Pet friendly, and Open Hearth took it beyond that. We felt our dog was welcomed. In our apartment was a treat bag, basket of blankets and a dog bed. We brought our own dog bed but it was nice they provided that. There's a large fence exercise area with waste receptacle bags. There's a separate pet friendly wing.

The pool and jacuzzi were nice, as well as clean. There were pool toys, a small child flotation vest and pool noodle. They also provided nice swim towels in that area. Had a shelf with games and books downstairs. Also provided games in our room.

Just a mile from downtown Sister Bay. Across the highway is a road that leads to Pebble Beach. Even with the snow my puppy and I were able to explore the beach.

Will definitely stay here again. The properly was also...

WOW! We are locals so don’t typically stay at area resorts, although we had a snow/ice storm that left us without power for 24 hours. Our home quickly became cold & we had no electricity & water. I called Open Hearth to ask if they had availability for the night & were dog friendly. Yes, they did & said they were giving discounts to residents affected by the outages. We quickly went to the resort & were completely enchanted & impressed by the facility. Very comfortable, homey & the staff felt like old friends. Very professional, caring & made sure all of our & our dogs expectations were met. This Lodge has several public cozy spaces with fireplaces & comfy furniture that makes it truly feel like home, The coffee is always on & plentiful! There is an indoor pool, whirlpool, exercise room, breakfast room & more. Their attention to detail in decor is unlike anything we’ve seen. They even had a container filled with snow brushes for guests to use to clean off their cars. They really think of everything. You can tell this lodge is run by caring, loving people who love what they do. The rooms are comfortable & very clean. There were surprises for our dog which she loved! The grounds are beautiful…some wooded, some open areas, play spaces for children, several outdoor fire pit areas, an enclosed dog “park,” and even free dog washing/bathing room to use inside. Although we live here….we will be back to this amazing place for a change of scenery! Thank you from the bottom...