Keating Pizza
Keating Pizza things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Description
Ratings
Posts
Craving pizza, I thought I’d try Keating Pizza for the first time. My cell phone was having issues so I couldn’t call ahead. Once there, I was told it would be about 25 minutes for a medium pizza so I chose 4 slices of pepperoni pizza which is the same size as a medium pizza but more expensive - I paid $26.25! Once home we attempted to eat the slices but couldn’t make it past a few bites each. Worst pizza on the island! They use the cheapest “pretend” pepperoni, sliced thick and double stacked - it was vile and actually made me nauseous! The sauce was “passable”, a bit sweet but no bearing on an authentic Italian sauce. Then they piled on cheese overtop everything. The crust was just so-so but there was way too much cheese. An extremely disappointing meal. And it wasn’t cheap either. I will not be returning.
Nor ShoreNor Shore
120
I really don’t know why I keep coming back here. The slices that are gone weren’t eaten, we placed them on the other side of the box to try and soak up some of the oil. The entire box ended up going into the garbage as I wouldn’t even let my dog eat this stuff. The pizza we got tonight was really sloppy and unappetizing. The dough was either not cooked long enough or there was too much sauce but all the slices in the box are soaked with so much oil that the liner inside the pizza box was soaked through. Every time my partner and I order pizza from here it looks like this. I really don’t know why we thought MAYBE this time it wouldn’t be as gross, but nope. Now we definitely won’t be coming back. What a shame.
Teyah SweeneyTeyah Sweeney
140
Nearby Restaurants Of Keating Pizza
Tonollis Deli
Keating Coffee
Subway

Tonollis Deli
4.6
(203)$$
Click for details

Keating Coffee
4.7
(118)$
Click for details

Subway
3.8
(75)$
Click for details