Vito's Lovingston — Restaurant in Amherst

We were really looking forward to trying Vito’s Pizza, but unfortunately, the food was a huge letdown. I ordered a panini, but what I got was definitely not a panini. It was just dry, boiled chicken with no flavor—barely any seasoning besides salt and pepper—and practically no sauce. The "pesto" was barely there and didn’t help the situation.

My husband’s pasta was watery, bland, and completely lacking in flavor. Our friends ordered a calzone and the vodka pasta. The calzone was okay, but again, the pasta was just as bland and watery. The shrimp in their dishes tasted like it came from the freezer and hadn’t been heated through properly.

To top it off, the vodka sauce wasn’t even pink—it was white and watery, which was honestly confusing. The only things we actually enjoyed were the bruschetta and the sweet potato fries.

Our waitress was kind but hardly around. Overall, the food was flavorless, poorly executed, and just not worth returning for. Disappointed and...

I LOVE LOVE LOVE 😍 Vito's! Tiffany, our server and quite frankly, a VERY integral facet OF Vito's, was as usual (Not that ANYTHING about her usual) absolutely Wonderful! I sooooo appreciate how she ALWAYS takes care of us, no matter how difficult we are and no matter how hard her day has been, she's always there making sure we, "We" as in All her customers, feel like we're never a bother, nothing is too much to ask, a readily smile and friendly personality round out the package of our amazing Tiffany!

We ordered pizza's tonight and therein again, as par for the course when it comes to Vito's, they were Wonderful! Very, VERY flavorful! The sauce is packed full of zesty, rich, enticing, Italian flavor done right!

For Wonderful Food, Atmosphere, and Friendship, you'll never be...

A generally disappointing visit. Two servers for the entire restaurant to handle all the tables, take to go orders, bus tables, and receive payment. Then when I received my food (a meatball Parmesan sub) not only were the meatballs cold, but they were covered in a thick layer of pamesan cheese rendering them pretty much inedible. The sandwich was described on the menu as meatballs with red sauce and mozzarella cheese, no mention of Parmesan cheese and traditionally that type of cheese is added at the table not by the cooks. The waitstaff were, however, very friendly and they comped my disgusting...