Lost Pizza Co. Auburn — Restaurant in Auburn

A refreshing take on pizza in Auburn.

You walk in, order, and go find a seat. I like that. I can watch The Price Is Right or hockey. The service is really good and you see people helping each other. Happy employees equals happy customers.

We as a table ordered an Otis pizza which is like a meat lovers, a chicken spaghetti, a sandwich that was ham and cheese with a sauce, and a pepperoni and sausage pizza.

I had the pepp sausage because I wanted something simple to just get a taste for their dough, sauce, and cheese. I was impressed. I will be honest and say that their style of toppings and flavors is best applied to thin crusts. We had thin crust and it was delicious. The slices held their shape, but there was just enough soft to it. I love the sauce. It’s got a little more tang to it than most places with a sweet sauce. I don’t like a sugary, high acid sauce. I like a robust tomato flavor and seasoning. This is that. The cheese isn’t super chunky or heavy. They give you enough of it, but not so much that you’re sitting there just chewing a ball of cheese. The ratio for their dough sauce and cheese is good. The toppings were good and I want to explore their menu but I must say, I see a pepperoni and jalapeño pizza to go in my future from here often. Because get this. The place is sweet but it’s also crazy affordable for eating out. One thing I couldn’t believe was how cheap a personal pizza was. And it’s cooked fresh. You can get a small with a few toppings for around 10 bucks +/- depending on what you order. I feel like a lot of places start at 10 or 12 for just cheese. So that’s pretty sweet.

The vibe is super laid back. It’s just a groovy place to grab a bite from a diverse menu and hang out with other people laughing it up.

I can’t wait...

Great atmosphere. Good service and prices. Decent pizza.

This place is brand new to the area but they seem to be functioning like a well oiled machine already, and they were packed. The service was great.

Lots of options to choose from, which I appreciate. The prices are very reasonable. The atmosphere is pretty cool and very family friendly. This would be a great place to take the whole family. I probably wouldn't go here for "great pizza" but would go here for an easy and pretty good family meal without breaking the bank.

We tried the Hot Chick Pizza, a sausage pizza, a bacon pizza, and a pepperoni and roasted garlic pizza. Plus breadsticks and fried ravioli.

Definitely go for thin crust, we did not care for the regular crust at all.

The kids enjoyed their pizza, and my pepperoni and roasted garlic pizza was good. The wife's Hot Chick Pizza (buffalo chicken pizza) was not something we would order again, it just wasn't good.

Breadsticks were very plain and the fried ravioli is meat filled, not cheese, which I didn't love.

Their red sauce/pizza sauce is very plain and not a whole lot of flavor there. Almost a Midwest vibe to it.

Overall, big points on service, prices, options, and the restaurant itself. Mid score on the pizza. Low points on the sauce, bread sticks, and ravioli.

I'd give them a B...

My family and I went for dinner tonight. My wife ordered a small thin crust cheese pizza which she said was very good. My son ordered a small thin crust Otis which he said was good. I ordered a large thin crust Italian sausage and green pepper pizza. The first pizza they brought out was a small Italian sausage and pepperoni thick crust pizza which they said they made by mistake and gave it to us for free while the made the correct pizza. Second pizza they brought out was a small, green pepper and Italian sausage thick crust pizza. They apologized for the mistake and brought that pizza back. The third pizza they brought out the waitress apologized right away and said she was not sure why the kitchen was having issues with making this order since it was wrong again, and asked if I wanted it. It was a large Italian sausage and green pepper THICK crust pizza. I agreed to just take that pizza and we took it to go since my wife and son were long done eating their pizzas. My pizza was okay, I am not much of a fan of thick crust pizza.

The waitress was very nice and apologetic. We may try again since my wife and son enjoyed...