Colatina Exit — Restaurant in Bradford

I moved to the area from Nashville, TN where we have excellent food. I was incredibly impressed when I walked into this restaurant to find excellent service, great portions, very reasonable prices and amazing food. My husband and I struggle to find restaurants with decent sized portions and Colatina doesn’t disappoint, we always go home with plenty of leftovers. They have great specials and deals; such as their Monday specialty pizzas for $10, Tuesday’s they have large pizzas for $12, etc. My husband and I eat here once a week for our date night (not since covid though). Everything on the menu is very well executed from their steak to their seafood pasta, Cajun chicken pasta, spinach and artichoke dip, their MASSIVE calzones and mouth watering pizza. Colatina has never let us down. During their brunch on Sunday’s they offer a maple butter with their bread and it’s amazing, I would purchase a tub of it if I could! We ask for it when we eat dinner and they bring it with no hesitation. The servers are kind and excellent at what they do. The ambiance of the restaurant is very soothing and well thought out. They have been doing an excellent job adjusting to COVID and taking good care of their customers. I will be a customer here for as...

I've never actually ordered food, besides pizza, from the Colatina until today. (I grew up close to the restaurant). Sadly that was a mistake.

By far the worst, most under cooked steak, I've ever received from a restaurant. I used to be a chef myself, and I've traveled across four continents so far. Genuinely this was the worst steak I've gotten. Of course it was take out too. So I didn't even get to explain what was wrong with it. The presentation was decent, the worker knew how to sear a steak at least. They just didn't know how to cook it. As parts were still raw. Hopefully they can get some more practice in. All the side dishes were okay. Not spectacular, but not bad either.

It can be tricky when one first starts out cooking steaks. As they can look done after searing them. However that doesn't not mean the inside was properly cooked. It's a mistake that gets made when people who aren't use to cooking steaks start out. Overall I'm not angry, mistakes happen, I'm just disappointed. For the price of the item and the lack of quality from such...

Definitely one of my favorite restaurants to eat at. The food is amazing especially the stuffed mushrooms, chicken wings and the seafood cioppino (with white sauce)are my favorites! However everything on their menu is amazing. The prices my be a little higher than average but it's absolutely worth it. They also deliver (or at least they did before the outbreak). And offer takeout as well. The people who work there are just as awesome as the food! Shout out to Dave, Jesse, Logan, Garrett and an old employee, Travis who always do an excellent job, and aim to please the customers. (Sorry if I forgot anyone) If you are a local than you already know how awesome this place is, however if you are not, stop by Colatina!! You will not be sorry. Almost forgot, they have a bar upstairs which is also great for those who enjoy a relaxing and fun night out with family/friends. Overall I would say this is my favorite local restaurants and would highly...