This is our second time eating food from Mikey Bagels. The first time we ordered online, picked up and ate at home. I ordered a pork roll, egg and cheese on an egg bagel. I feel like their egg bagels could use a hint more salt in them but otherwise that, it was delicious.
Today we came in, ordered in and ate in. The woman that took our order was very nice and friendly. She took our order correctly because I was able to read it on the small screen in front of me. We went around 12:30 p.m. and it wasn't crowded. There were some people that came in and out while we were there and a few that sat and ate in.
I had a cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, a sunny side up egg, all on an egg bagel. We shared an order of mozzarella sticks. My boyfriend had a cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato and onions on a garlic bagel.
The mozzarella sticks were delicious The breading was perfect and crispy. They were not greasy or too salty. My only complaint is that the marinara sauce was very cold and I didn't like the cold marinara sauce on the hot mozzarella stick. My tastes buds were confused. Besides that, they were perfect!
My burger order was supposed to come with a sunny side up egg on it which was missing so I did have to send it back to get the egg. Due to the egg shortage, eggs have an extra charge so I definitely wanted to make sure I got my egg! After they brought back my sandwich, the egg was not sunny side up and was overcooked and just fried which I wasn't crazy about. The burger was a little too cooked for my taste. It was well done but it's also a thinner burger. I normally eat my burgers medium. Overall I would say it was a good burger. This is the first time I've had a burger on a bagel before and that was an interesting combination that I enjoyed and would get again. I would also like to make a recommendation that they put two slices of cheese on their burgers because one slice really doesn't do much. My boyfriend said the same thing about the cheese. He enjoyed his sandwich and said it was very good.
Both Burger sandwiches came with fries and the fries were also delicious. They had the perfect combination of crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. They were not too salty but also didn't require additional salt.
We finished up our food and when we went to leave, the very friendly lady at the front said goodbye to us which was very nice. We will definitely be...
Read moreI’ve been going here at least once a week for the past 6 months. Their food is really good. I’m celiac so seeing that they added new gluten free options like bagels and wraps was exciting. I tried the wraps twice and the second time I got it they must’ve forgot to use a gluten free wrap and I was sick the whole day. The next week when I came back for another order I informed the owner of the mistake and what happened to me. He basically said oops and that he hopes it wasn’t their food despite me telling him that that was all I had eaten that day. I didn’t expect anything in return but wanted to make sure they were more careful but he handled it pretty badly.
Recently i went there for another online order. They were slightly crowded and probably not enough employees so I was more than okay waiting for my food. It only took an extra 5 minutes and I was on my way. When I got home I noticed they didn’t give me one of the bagels I had ordered. I called and let them know I was coming back for it and what exactly was missing and what was on the bagel. When I returned to pick up the bagel they handed it to me. But when I got into the car I noticed it was completely wrong. Wrong cream cheese and missing toppings. I had to go back in a THIRD time just to get the correct bagel. Now I feel like I have to tip toe around to make sure I get the right food and all of it.
Update: after another messed up order which I didn’t really mind. They were remaking it for the second time and the manager came up to me and assumed that I was the person that wrote this review. Instead of messaging me privately before assuming who I was, he came up to me and just started talking about it in front of the customers and workers without asking me if I wanted to. On top of that he was defending himself and his business for what happened. Now I get that there were probably some miscommunications and what not but apologizing in his favor was beyond inappropriate. Due to the fact that I was overwhelmed with my own problems, the messed up order, and the conversation that came out of the blue, I left the restaurant crying. I will never ever be back and I will definitely be warning friends and family of all of these encounters. I really loved the food and the place when they first opened but I’ve given them too many chances and it...
Read moreI stopped in a couple weeks ago to get a bagel and opted for the cinnamon raisin with cream cheese. The bagel was very good and they didn't skimp on the cream cheese, but I was a bit shocked a bagel with cream cheese was $3.45.
When I was there the first time, I noticed they had other breakfast options so I decided to take my daughter on a Saturday morning. She ordered pancakes with chocolate chips and I ordered the eggs benedict. My daughter loves chocolate chip pancakes but only ate about 1/3 and took the rest home. When I asked how they were she said they were "okay" and she didn't have any desire to finish them when we got home.
The eggs benedict is supposed to come with home fries which, as you can see from the picture, did not. Instead it came with a tiny cup of fruit. What you will also see in the picture is a bunch of mixed greens which are not listed on the menu. I knew it came with avocado and tomato but I was not expecting mixed greens. Instead of avocado slices, there was an extremely thin layer of mashed avocado and whatever spices they put in it were not to my liking. The Capicola was very thin and had very little flavor as was the case with the hollandaise sauce so all I could taste were the mixed greens and whatever spices they'd put in the mashed avocado. On top of that, trying to cut through the toppings and a bagel with a plastic knife was not very easy. Providing an actual knife would have been nice.
In addition to the food, we each got a drink from the cooler so our total was just under $25. I'm all for trying new places and supporting small businesses, but there are several diners in the area where I can get the same food which tastes much better for the same...
Read more