Lily's Pizza Niche — Restaurant in Cloverdale

I gave this restaurant multiple chances because I have eaten there since the Johnsons opened the business more than 30 years ago, then the Randall's and now this one, which has not been very long so you can’t look at the older reviews. Everytime we visit family, we come in 2 to 3 times a year at least ($400 a year customer minimum, lost) take that times 10, 20, 40 customers, it adds up. The girl that now supposedly runs the place has lied to us EVERYTIME we have went in the business. I have seen posts multiple times of closings and then posts deleted. For example, this last visit, another closing, 1 hour before the business was scheduled to open. We had been in before Christmas and she told us while we were in the dining room people were always complaining about her being closed and that you know how small towns are and then she did it after her announced holiday. The ingredients ARE NOT the same, everyone who has eaten it for a lifetime knows that. Last visit to Indiana, same thing. We were talking about the crust and she was telling us how people were complaining about the crust and I asked her point blank if she had changed it because we all thought it didn't taste the same and she admitted she had while telling the Community she hasn't changed anything. The sauce is different also. I don't understand why you have to lie about it. Having to take to Google because they deleted/blocked comments, users and FB posts to protect their ratings, but when your reputation throughout the community is already negative, one person with years of business experience, including restaurant management and having owned an actual mystery shopping company, who offered suggestions, ideas and insight which was supposedly appreciated at the time, shouldn't damage what is already damaged. The main thing this restaurant has going for it is nostalgia. The people who grew up eating here under the Johnson ownership KNOW and they also KNOW it's not the same, it's similar at best and expensive. You can't trust Facebook reviews because if you say anything negative or give bad reviews, she deletes and blocks you and her community of family and friends attack you. Always call first before you make the trip, or like us on more than one occasion, you may make it for nothing. Someone made a comment that it would literally take the Johnsons coming back to fix it and I believe that...

Ordered Sat around 615. They said it would be ready in 35min. Got there pretty much as they were boxing it up. It was super quiet in there, and a bit chilly even with customers. Could use a TV or some low music in back ground, just my preference. Place was clean, smelled great and had cute gift items to purchase. I ordered a large pizza with several toppings and dipping sauces. Staff was great. Pizza was still warm when I got it home. It was delicious. Cost less than $40. Worth it. This is 2nd time and now I'm not sure i can have pizza from any other place. I 4got to take pics of pizza. It was between a thin and hand...

Anytime my family and I come to Indiana we always take a trip to Lily's Pizza Niche. The food is always on point. My parents live in Indianapolis and they love to take a trip for this pizza. The customer service is always 👌. I am very particular about my pizza and so are my sons. Hands down this is one of there favorites. I recommend this pizza and the other items on the menu to my Hoosiers family. All the ladies that work there are always hustling to get the orders done! Great food, great people and a great experience. Can't wait to go back to Indiana and get...