Terita's Pizza — Restaurant in Columbus

An Ohio must try pizza. You’re welcome.

Consistency will promise that the pizza I rave about for the past decade will still be the pizza you get to experience. Flavor is a premium. The pepperoni is Old World recipe zesty with that baked puckering curl. I beg you not to skip the sausage (see pic). It’s a house recipe that they have made locally. It’s the only place I know in a large radius that cooks their sausage on the pizza, so none of those juicy flavors escape your meal. Sure it’s not a meal on the healthy nutrition radar, but it is pizza after all. Now we love a thin crust (see pic), and their regular is donato’s thin. But if you need it to go thinner, they can accommodate with their extra thin cracker like crust. Sauce is good without being sweet and sugary. Thick cardboard box to keep it hot for the ride home. Oh yeah, it’s carryout only, if you didn’t get that from their name. Not a table or restroom in site. Carryout beverage coolers, and some daily specials (see pic). Accurate on...

I keep hearing this is one of the best pizza joints in Cbus so I had to try it. I went there after work on a Friday shortly after they opened and there was already at least 5 other people in the small store waiting for their orders, so they definitely are quite popular. When I finally got to try the pizza, I thought, yeah it's good, but worth the hype? Naw, can't say it is. I think if you're an old school food type of person, then this will hit the mark. But in 2025, there's better stuff out there. Garlic bread doesn't have to be store bought french bread cut in half with deli sliced mozz on it. I could make this at 2am in the morning with a toaster oven. My guess is, that's the way they've always done it, so they don't want to change. And that's fine. If it was in front of me, sure, I'd eat it. But will I go out of my way for it? That's a negative,...

Terita's Pizza: A Columbus Gem (5 stars)

Terita's Pizza is a must-try for anyone looking for an incredible pizza experience in Columbus. Here's why it gets 5 stars from me:

Legendary Flavor: They've been serving up delicious pies for over 60 years, and you can taste the tradition in every bite. The fresh ingredients shine through. Award-Winning Goodness: They've been voted #1 Pizzeria in Columbus for a reason! Their dedication to quality is evident. More Than Just Pizza: While their pizza is the star, their menu offers a variety of subs, and salads that are all equally satisfying. Family Feel: This family-owned gem has a warm and welcoming atmosphere. You can tell they care about their customers and their community. Overall, Terita's Pizza is a Columbus classic that delivers on every level. Highly recommend...