Plus 1 Pizza — Restaurant in Coshocton

I posted a review previously about Plus 1 possibly having staffing issues due to their inability to deliver at certain times, gave them two stars because of this....well I'm not sure if the timing thing HAS changed or not. However I have been eating the crap out of their "Godfather stromboli" fashioned into more of a genuine calzone when they personalize it with ricotta for me at my request! Let's just say I feel my review previously of TWO stars was unjust; I have to consciously stop myself from ordering their food and subsequently waddling everywhere lol. Great menu, with actual (not mainstream fresh standards!) freshly baked crusts and customizable options along with their standard pizzas (which are pretty non-standard IMO).

Even if I do have to wait until a certain hour or drive a few minutes into town to pickup, their delicious-ness AND super awesome staff are totally worth it to me. I refuse to order from any other pizza shop around since I went ahead and tried them one more time, so happy I did!

BTW, when you offer your e-mail you get rewards points. Easily acquired with each purchase. After each order I get an e-mail with my...

I gave a 1 because there was not a 0, we have ordered a lot of pizza from them and the pizza was always very good and the service was always fast, well a few weeks ago when we ordered and we always have it delivered and always give a cash tip, well this time when we ordered we put it on our debit card for the pizza and gave a cash tip, well the next day when I checked my bank account someone wrote in their own tip, I called to talk to the manager and he wasn't there so I told the guy that answered the phone why I was calling, he looked at the receipts and found that someone wrote a tip on it he said he would tell the manager and to this day I have not heard from the manager so needless to say they have lost our business and it's a shame because we loved...

Wow! I am glad I called. I am gonna go ahead and put it out there.. This is the best pizza I have ever had period. Not just best delivery pizza or pizza joint pizza, the best I have ever had anywhere. Chicago, New York, California....you know, those places that have pizza named after them, this was better. If I lived anywhere near here you would get to know me real well because you would see me often. I know it's a lot to hope for but would it be possible for you to extend your delivery radius to 400 miles? No, dont answer, I have to walk away holding out at least some hope that I can do this again....seriously, thank you, that was an experience to...