Pizza Point — Restaurant in Coshocton

My partner, Robert Cosmar, and I grew up in Coshocton many years ago and then moved away. Pizza Point Pizza has always been our yardstick for how pizza should taste in states, far and wide, over the past 50 years.

Recently, Robert made a visit to Coshocton to visit his family. Both of us were excited to again taste Pizza Point Pizza and before returning home, he bought the largest one he could, wrapped it in plastic, then lovingly placed it in a cooler for the long drive home to Florida.

We both wonder what happened to our yardstick ... the familiar has been replaced with the unknown. It was bland and tasteless. There is, most sadly, nothing noteworthy about it any more ... Sincerely, CJ...

The pros: Prices are good. They give a good ammount of toppings for the price as well.

The cons: Pizza was only mediocre. Ingredients tasted low quality, especially the cheese. Dough was not great. Sauce was a little overpowering and not very good. Location does not accept credit cards. 40 minute wait for a small pizza seems really high. Location is also standing room only, and doesn't have any dining area. If this is the best pizza in Coshocton, I would be very sad to see the other...

Have always enjoyed the pizza here. Called last night at 10pm, they closed at 11. Woman who answered the phone was extremely unprofessional, sighed loudly when I asked if I could still place an order, then when I asked for extra toppings on one of the pizza's she said they can't do that because it's a special. I said I'll pay the extra for the extra toppings and she said we can't do that here?! Did not place the order. Don't know if I'll order...