Nicko’s NY Pizza — Restaurant in Euharlee

Great pizza place🤗 We got a 12" Overachiever for 2 people and it was amazing - plenty! They customized it, and it was done in less than 15 minutes on a busy Saturday night. The cheese tasted like it was freshly grated (didn't have that cornmill dried out tastelessness that so many other pizza places have). The crust was ridiculously crispy on the outside and soft on the inside - like a dream. The sausage and pepperoni were incredibly fresh and not too greasy - just right. They had an arcade with some great games for kids or whoever. Really impressive...

It's a small place and likely to be a local favorite. We got a basic 12", sausage and cheese pizza to try it. We weren't disappointed. The crust wasn't overly doughy and had a crispness like a pan pizza should. It wasn't flimsy/wimpy with the weight of topping. The sauce and cheese ratio was perfect (imo). They gave you enough of an edge to hold on to the pizza but not so much that you'd feel shorted of pizza.

They also have salads and hand dipped ice cream. I didn't try the salad but I don't think it's last visit. We...

My first visit, I didn't know what to expect, so i ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and a drink. It arrived quickly and was hot and tasty. The slice was hanging off the edges of the paper plate it was delivered on, so a $5.00 slice is a good value. Drinks are self service. The building is an old historical building and the wood floors are somewhat uneven in places. All-in-all, a wonderful experience. Although I did not try it out, there is a small game room in a room at the back...