This place is a small town gem. Partner and I passed through the area driving back to Champaign. The guy working there was super nice and generous. Partner got a cone and I got the Shake special (cinnamon toast crunch, totally bomb and packed full of cereal!). We were impressed by the quality and creativity of the ice cream. Would definitely stop in again and try the affogato if we're ever driving...
Read moreEVERYTHING at this place is great! The iced oatmeal, chocolate chip and peanut butter cookies were to die for. Hot chocolate made with whole milk and Ghiradeli chocolate and whipped cream was fabulous. The ice creams from a Madison, WI chocolate shop were fantastic too. And it's not expensive....
Read moreWe are so lucky to have Main Street Cookies & Cream in Fisher! Jessica made special order cookies for an open house celebration and they were such a hit. I appreciated the individually wrapped cookies as guests could easily leave with a "gift" to...
Read more