HTML SitemapExplore

New York Pizza Fleming Island — Restaurant in Florida

Name
New York Pizza Fleming Island
Description
Nearby attractions
Nearby restaurants
Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co.
1811 Golden Eagle Way #23, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Yianni’s Kitchen
1831 Golden Eagle Way Suite 29, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
1811 Golden Eagle Way Ste 20, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island
2349 Village Square Pkwy #101, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Asian House
2349 Village Square Pkwy, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Nearby local services
Steel Mill Total Wellness
2320 Market Dr, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Steel Mill Total Wellness
2320 Market Dr, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Achieve Fitness
2349 Village Square Pkwy Suite 110 & 111, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
New York Pizza Fleming Island tourism.New York Pizza Fleming Island hotels.New York Pizza Fleming Island bed and breakfast. flights to New York Pizza Fleming Island.New York Pizza Fleming Island attractions.New York Pizza Fleming Island restaurants.New York Pizza Fleming Island local services.New York Pizza Fleming Island travel.New York Pizza Fleming Island travel guide.New York Pizza Fleming Island travel blog.New York Pizza Fleming Island pictures.New York Pizza Fleming Island photos.New York Pizza Fleming Island travel tips.New York Pizza Fleming Island maps.New York Pizza Fleming Island things to do.
New York Pizza Fleming Island things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
New York Pizza Fleming Island
United StatesFloridaNew York Pizza Fleming Island

Basic Info

New York Pizza Fleming Island

1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island, FL 32003
4.5(312)$$$$
Open until 12:00 AM
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: , restaurants: Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co., Yianni’s Kitchen, Jeremiah's Italian Ice, Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island, Asian House, local businesses: Steel Mill Total Wellness, Steel Mill Total Wellness, Achieve Fitness
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(904) 579-3488
Website
nypizzafi.com
Open hoursSee all hours
MonClosedOpen

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Reviews

Live events

Paint, Connect & Reflect: A Guided Art Workshop
Paint, Connect & Reflect: A Guided Art Workshop
Sat, Jan 31 • 4:00 PM
Jacksonville, Florida, 32207
View details
Visit Jacksonvilles historical Urban Core
Visit Jacksonvilles historical Urban Core
Mon, Jan 26 • 4:00 PM
Jacksonville, Florida, 32202
View details
Candlelight: Tribute to Adele
Candlelight: Tribute to Adele
Sat, Jan 31 • 6:30 PM
303 N Main St, Jacksonville, 32202
View details

Nearby restaurants of New York Pizza Fleming Island

Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co.

Yianni’s Kitchen

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island

Asian House

Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co.

Brew-Bakers Cafe & Co.

4.9

(81)

$

Open until 12:00 AM
Click for details
Yianni’s Kitchen

Yianni’s Kitchen

4.7

(38)

$

Click for details
Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4.6

(101)

$

Closed
Click for details
Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island

Mr Chubbys - Fleming Island

4.0

(655)

$

Closed
Click for details

Nearby local services of New York Pizza Fleming Island

Steel Mill Total Wellness

Steel Mill Total Wellness

Achieve Fitness

Steel Mill Total Wellness

Steel Mill Total Wellness

4.8

(103)

Click for details
Steel Mill Total Wellness

Steel Mill Total Wellness

4.6

(14)

Click for details
Achieve Fitness

Achieve Fitness

4.7

(97)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Reviews of New York Pizza Fleming Island

4.5
(312)
avatar
3.0
2y

My family and I ate here the other day and I wasn't very impressed. Pizza was just ok, a little tough. The kind you have to rip apart rather than it tear apart. A little soggy /floppy in the middle too. The wings had good flavor but were definitely overcooked. The salad wasn't great but not the worst I've ever had. We got a garden salad, which was just iceburg, black ilives, tomatoes, red onion and croutons. The ranch tasted like it was Hidden Valley, which I'm not a fan of. They only do bottled drinks and charge $1.99 for a bottle of Aquafina water, not a big bottle either. The drinks, straight out of the fridge, weren't very cold and they don't have an ice machine or cups. Coukd have used a few more plates. They only gave us 5 plates for 5 of us to share a salad, pizza, wings and garlic bread and they're the cheapest paper, bending, leak through the bottom...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
4y

Decided to get take out 3 days ago based on reviews. Ordered a calzone with pepperoni and mushroom and a pizza roll with spinach and tomato. Crusts on both very good, however, calzone was way overloaded with mozzarella and ricotta cheese was nothing but a small smear. The pepperoni and mushroom I paid 1.79 extra for each were non existent. As far as the pizza roll, same situation. Granted the pizza roll is mozzarella only,but cooks remember... spinach welts down,need to accommodate for that. Called and spoke with manager that evening, she was understanding and asked what would I like her to do. I said please refund me the 34.00 dollars. She said she would and it would take 3-5 days. Sure hope this happens, otherwise I just spent 34.00 dollars that we threw...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
10y

What happened to New York Pizza? The only place that had my ChickenPhilly sub. A ChickenPhilly is made the same way as a PhillyCheeseSteak only it's with "Shredded" chicken. Instead I got chicken strips, hardly any lettuce, the mayo was mysteriously absent and I think there was a few fried onions, Definitely not the Extra Fried Onions I had requested. Oh and on top of that, Literally, was the melted cheese and not much of it. My husbands cheesesteak was the same. The cheese was melted on TOP of the lettuce and tomato, and again the mayo was a no show. Ditto on the last cheesesteak ordered. No seasoning, no mushrooms that were ordered. A HUGE waste of time and money. They Were our go to sub shop but not anymore. So the hunt for a decent sub...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Donnell WyattDonnell Wyatt
This was my first time trying this place. The lunch special was expensive, $10.74 for 2 slices and a drink. Sadly, it wasn't good. I had the works and the chic fil a pizza slices. To be honest, I have had frozen pizza that tastes better than this. The only plus was the convenient location. I honestly cannot return to this place again. The dining room is also used for store near the back. Don't know why this is the case, since they have another storage space next door. Their food quality really needs to be improved. Right now, their pricing has surpassed their quality.
Danielle LarawayDanielle Laraway
Update: got the caesar salad; t was delicious! For my lunch of 2 slices of pizza (BBQ and chicken & ranch), 2 garlic knots, and a drink, it was just over $10. It was plenty of food for the price. The pizza was really good, my favorite being the ranch one. The garlic knots were amazing, as well as the garlic butter drizzled over them. Their drinks right now ate bottled only, but a variety to choose from including Gatorade, soda, energy drinks, tea, or water. The restaurant was clean and modern. The staff were friendly and efficient in their service.
Tamoa ArroyoTamoa Arroyo
Love the Pizza! We're New Yorkers who have NOT had good NY Pizza in Florida. Well, the search is over! New York Pizza delivered! My husband and I are very please. The crust was perfect! Crunchy, but not Burned. The sauce and cheese ratio was distributed perfectly. What a delight! I can't wait to try other items on the menu.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

This was my first time trying this place. The lunch special was expensive, $10.74 for 2 slices and a drink. Sadly, it wasn't good. I had the works and the chic fil a pizza slices. To be honest, I have had frozen pizza that tastes better than this. The only plus was the convenient location. I honestly cannot return to this place again. The dining room is also used for store near the back. Don't know why this is the case, since they have another storage space next door. Their food quality really needs to be improved. Right now, their pricing has surpassed their quality.
Donnell Wyatt

Donnell Wyatt

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Update: got the caesar salad; t was delicious! For my lunch of 2 slices of pizza (BBQ and chicken & ranch), 2 garlic knots, and a drink, it was just over $10. It was plenty of food for the price. The pizza was really good, my favorite being the ranch one. The garlic knots were amazing, as well as the garlic butter drizzled over them. Their drinks right now ate bottled only, but a variety to choose from including Gatorade, soda, energy drinks, tea, or water. The restaurant was clean and modern. The staff were friendly and efficient in their service.
Danielle Laraway

Danielle Laraway

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Love the Pizza! We're New Yorkers who have NOT had good NY Pizza in Florida. Well, the search is over! New York Pizza delivered! My husband and I are very please. The crust was perfect! Crunchy, but not Burned. The sauce and cheese ratio was distributed perfectly. What a delight! I can't wait to try other items on the menu.
Tamoa Arroyo

Tamoa Arroyo

See more posts
See more posts