SQUARE PEG PIZZERIA HIGGANUM — Restaurant in Haddam

If I could rate this negative stars I would do so. We just moved to Middletown. We got a flyer in the mail and are looking to find “our new places” to go. So we went. What a mistake. A large pizza, garlic bread and 2 sodas were $39.71. I gave them $40 I guess they decided I did not need my change back. Anyway, the place is filthy. The table had dried ice cream and other items adhered to the table - they clearly had been there quite some time. The massive cob web in the corner above us was disturbing. Now the food. Have you ever been to Chuck E Cheese? Well then you have had this pizza before. Limp crust, it was cold and tasteless. The sauce for the garlic bread was freezing cold. There is really no place to sit. It’s not a restaurant, the main space is taken with corn hole and then a bar. Then advertise your place as such. So disappointed. It might be in a brick oven but frozen pizza in my oven would have been better. Oh and we had to go pick up our items when they were ready and bus our own table when we were done. Yeah needless to say we will never be back and if you were smart you will...

1 star is generous. If I could rate 0 stars I would. I usually don’t spend the time to write reviews but this was so bad I had to. Let’s start off with that a large pizza is about 30 dollars and you only get 4 slices. Ordered a Margherita pizza which on their menu claims to be fresh mozzarella and basil. There was absolutely no basil on the pizza and it wasn’t fresh mozzarella. It was some squares of cheese (guessing cheddar) cut up and melted onto the pizza. The pizza was also freezing cold. I asked for 2 sodas and didn’t receive them. The cheesy garlic bread was also missing basil and was freezing cold. I called to make a complaint and to see if I could be refunded. They don’t have a manager so there was “nothing they could do”. Apparently they were out of basil and mozzarella. What Italian pizza restaurant is out of those ingredients, and why sell to a customer without warning them they don’t have those ingredients. Girl on the phone was nice.. I feel bad that she has to work at a joke of a restaurant like this. Place needs to...

I dont know how a place can mess up something as easy as making pizza.. i called tonight to order 1 Large half pepperoni pizza. When i called, they picked up and hung up on me. I called back from 2 different phones about a dozen times. They never answered. So i went on their website and placed an order from there. Its about as simple as it gets, half pepperoni. First of all, it was 33.22 for one large pizza. Thats absurd to start. I got an order confirmation, with the correct order. I sent my friend to pick up the pizza. They charged him, after i had already paid online. And they gave him a large double pepperoni pizza on the entire pizza. They eventually fixed it. But for 33 dollars, they should have sprinkled gold ontop of it and had the correct order ready, on time. Get it together. And stop being so greedy. Pepes doesnt even...