Visited for the first time tonight and had a great experience! We ordered a large with a lot of toppings! The owner came out to let us know it would take a few extra minutes to make sure it was cooked correctly! In the meantime we opted to sit at one of the handful of tables. We were treated to the history of the building (saloon, diner, pizza place) which dates back to the turn of the century. The original tin punch ceiling is exposed and is a delightful addition to the space. Our pizza arrived and we quickly realized that this is not your average pizza. Toppings were fresh and generous. The sauce is made in house and has just the right amount of sweetness. The crust has a nice bite and was perfectly cooked. As we ate we watched a steady stream of takeout orders. We took home enough for a late night snack and made a note to add this to our...
Read moreYou might not know this if you're local, but ohio pizza is no good. However if you're from one of those pretentious pizza cities/nj, you'll be happy you stopped here. This place is way better than it has any right to be, based on geography, and proves that it's not "the water" that makes the pizza good, but the people. God bless the pizza people in Elmore Ohio.
The pizza place is open earlier than the bistro. When my girlfriend and I were there, there were literally 10 or so people just milling about outside like extras waiting for the pizza scene to start. It was the strangest thing I've ever seen. But in this town, there is nothing more important than the pizza apparently. Until they get to sit down and order food, they just mill...
Read moreI ordered their Sunday special and while picking it up via curbside, I mentioned that I was going to be brave and try their pickle pizza one day. Mike(employee delivering to my car) said he was going back in to eat his. So I jokingly said "how about bringing me a piece to try?" Mike said "hang on, I'll be right back. He added bacon/onions to his and it was still a really good pizza. I'm not sure I could eat anymore than a small size pizza but I'll definitely be ordering my own pickle pizza on my next visit. The special(pepperoni/ham) was as good as always. I like DeStazios pizza but it's their customer service that makes your visit...
Read more